The primary difference between social anxiety and social anxiety disorder is the severity of symptoms. Not everyone is affected in the same way, as the intensity and duration of symptoms can vary greatly from one person to another. Even though these conditions may seem similar in terms of traits and features across different individuals, each person’s experience is shaped by their environment, life events, and the diversity of human thoughts and behaviors. Furthermore, it is important to note that comorbidities—other mental health conditions that occur alongside social anxiety—are common. This highlights the complexity of social anxiety. Therefore, effective recovery strategies must address not only the causes and effects of the symptoms but also their associated conditions. Throughout this book, when recovery methods are discussed for social anxiety, performance anxiety, social phobia, and social anxiety disorder, they are meant to apply to each.
Research has shown that our neural network is a flexible organism, constantly adapting and rebuilding itself with each new piece of information. Scientists call this process neuroplasticity, a process that involves structural remodeling of the brain. By intentionally enhancing this process, we can actively change our thoughts, behaviors, and perspectives, developing new, healthy mindsets, skills, and abilities. All information signals our neural pathways to reorganize, leading to related changes in behavior and viewpoint. LINK
Video Series #2: Three Forms of Neuroplasticity
Reactive neuroplasticity is our brain’s natural response to sensory input. Active neuroplasticity involves neural changes gained through conscious effort, encompassing all forms of intentional learning. Proactive neuroplasticity is the deliberate, focused reshaping of our neural networks using tools and methods that support this process. The consistent, purposeful input of neural information allows us to proactively reshape our thoughts and behaviors, fostering healthy new mindsets, skills, and abilities. LINK
Proactive neuroplasticity involves deliberately and repeatedly inputting positive information into our neural network to strengthen learning and unlearning. What kind of information? How is it created? The goal is to ensure the information is of the highest quality to foster change. What are the best tools and techniques? What methodologies and psychological support systems are most effective for supporting proactive neuroplasticity—helping us unlearn negative self-beliefs reinforced by toxicity and replace them with healthy, positive ones. LINK
Video Series #4: Positive Personal Affirmations
We greatly underestimate the importance and power of PPAs because we don’t grasp the science behind them. PPAs are short, focused statements that we repeat to ourselves to describe what and who we want to become. PPAs help us concentrate on goals, challenge negative, self-defeating beliefs, and reprogram our subconscious minds. Practicing positive personal affirmations is a highly effective form of DRNI, or deliberate, repetitive input of neural information that supports proactive neuroplasticity. LINK
Video Series #5: Challenging Our Self-Destructive Thoughts
In this video, we explore the path our self-destructive thoughts take, which impacts our emotional well-being and overall quality of life. These thoughts originate from our negative core beliefs caused by our disorder, which shape our intermediate beliefs based on life experiences and form our ANTs or automatic negative thoughts that emphasize our situational fears and anxieties.LINK
By visualizing a positive outcome before facing a feared situation, we imagine behaving a certain way in a realistic scenario, and through repetition, we can achieve a genuine change in our behavior and perspective. This process is a form of proactive neuroplasticity, and all the associated neural benefits are gained. Just as our neural network cannot differentiate between toxic and healthy information, it also cannot distinguish between physical experience and imagination. LINK
Neural information is created by setting our goal, identifying the steps to achieve it, and determining the information—the self-affirming or motivating statement—we deliberately and repeatedly input into our neural network. We want this information to be authentic and well-constructed to fully engage positive neural responses. The integrity of our goal, objectives, and information influences the strength and effectiveness of the neural response. LINK
Coping mechanisms are tools and techniques that help us manage and reduce our situational anxieties and stress triggers. Part 1 emphasizes the psychological benefits of coping strategies and highlights the three main mechanisms—grounding, reframing, and rational response. In Part 2, or video #9, we will explore secondary coping mechanisms and how to use them properly, offering a comprehensive view of the most effective strategies for reducing our fears and anxieties. LINK
The video series explains the evolution of human neuroplasticity, distinguishing reactive, active, and proactive neural input. It diagrams the path of neural information and how it affects different lobes of the human brain responsible for learning.
Through proactive neuroplasticity, we compel our neural network to rewire its circuitry, leading to changes in behavior and perspective.
Social anxiety
Social anxiety is recognized across cultures by the ongoing fear and avoidance of social interactions and performance settings. This leads us to miss out on life experiences that help us connect with others. Adaptive coping strategies assist us in managing stress, anxiety, and their causes.
The primary goal of recovery from social anxiety is to alleviate our irrational fears and anxieties. We execute these goals through a three-pronged approach.
Produce rapid, concentrated positive stimulation to offset the abundance of negative information in our brain’s metabolism.
Reclaim and rebuild our self-esteem and reintegrate into society through recognition and reinforcement of our character strengths, virtues, attributes, and achievements.
Replace, offset, or overwhelm our irrational thoughts and behaviors with healthy, productive ones.
Neuroplasticity
The video series explains the evolution of neuroplasticity, highlighting the difference between reactive and active neural input versus proactive neural input. Videos illustrate how neural information progresses and affects the different lobes of the human brain involved in cognitive learning. Neural data, encoded as electrical energy, causes a receptive neuron to fire, transmitting this energy to a sensory neuron. This process allows the information to pass to millions of neurons involved in the network.
“Dr. Mullen is doing impressive work helping the world. He is the pioneer of proactive neuroplasticity utilizing DRNI—deliberate, repetitive, neural information.” — WeVoice (Madrid, Málaga)
Benefits of Neural Restructuring
The videos illustrate how this cellular chain reaction amplifies that initial electrical energy through an abundant neural response. Positive information input, positive energy multiplied countless times, and this positive energy is reciprocated generously. Each neural input of information influences millions of neurons as they reshape our neural network into a form that supports a positive self-image.
The beneficial effects of proactive neuroplasticity grow exponentially, fueled by the constant exchange of positive electrical energy and the release of hormones that promote motivation, persistence, and perseverance. Proactive neuroplasticity significantly reduces emotional dysfunction symptoms and helps us achieve our goals and objectives.
Hormones
Subsequently, natural hormonal neurotransmissions reward our activity with GABA for relaxation, dopamine for pleasure, endorphins for euphoria, serotonin for a sense of well-being, and hormones that support our motivation, enhance our memory, and improve concentration.
However, since our brain doesn’t distinguish between healthy and toxic information, the neurotransmission of pleasurable and motivational hormones happens regardless of whether we feed it self-destructive or constructive information. That’s one reason why breaking a habit, sticking to a resolution, or reaching our desired goal can be difficult. It also explains why positive informational input is essential for recovery and self-transformation.
The Inefficiency of One-Size-Fits-All Treatment
Contemporary wisdom questions the effectiveness of one-size-fits-all methods for behavioral change. These videos demonstrate how combining science with East-West psychologies best supports positive shifts in our thoughts and actions. Science offers us proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral techniques, and positive psychology’s focus on optimal functioning, which are Western approaches. Eastern practices contribute Abhidharma psychology and universal truths about ethical behavior.
Our core and intermediate beliefs shape our neural system. Childhood disturbances and emotional issues negatively influence these beliefs, leading to negative self-assessment that harms our emotional health and quality of life.
Hebbian Learning
The mechanics of Hebbian Learning explain how repeated proactive exposure to information leads to stronger, more effective learning. Hebb’s rule states that the more repetitions, the faster and more robust the connections become.
Harmful behaviors are unlearned, while healthy ones are adopted through deliberate, focused effort. Negative core and intermediate beliefs are challenged and replaced with healthy, life-affirming beliefs. Videos show how deliberately, repeatedly providing positive information reduces emotional dysfunction and helps us reach our goals.
Proactive neuroplasticity is conceptually simple but difficult because it demands long-term commitment and perseverance through repetitive practice. We reach Wimbledon after decades of playing on the courts. Philharmonics serve pianists who have spent years at the keyboard.
Proactive neuroplasticity requires a carefully planned routine of deliberate, repeated neural training that can be tedious and often fails to produce immediate tangible results, leading us to easily give up and lose hope in this age of instant gratification.
WHY IS YOUR SUPPORT SO NECESSARY AND ESSENTIAL? ReChanneling develops and implements programs to (1) mitigate symptoms of social anxiety and related conditions and (2) pursue personal goals and objectives – harnessing our intrinsic aptitude for extraordinary living. Our paradigmatic approach targets the personality through empathy, collaboration, and program integration utilizing neuroscience and psychology, including proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral modification, positive psychology, and techniques designed to regenerate self-esteem. All donations support scholarships for groups and workshops.
Committing to recovery is one of the hardest things you will ever do. It takes enormous courage and the realization that you are of value consequential, and deserving of happiness.
Recovery from Social Anxiety and Related Conditions
Robert F. Mullen Director/ReChanneling
For every new subscriber, ReChanneling donates $25 for workshop scholarships.
AI Generated: Our Symptoms Through a Personal Lense
The primary distinction between social anxiety and social anxiety disorder lies in the severity of symptoms. Not everyone is affected the same way; the intensity and persistence of symptoms vary widely from person to person. Although the characteristics and traits of these conditions may appear similar across individuals, each person’s experience is shaped by a unique combination of environment, life experiences, and the diversity of human thought and behavior.
Additionally, it is important to recognize that comorbidities—other mental health conditions that occur alongside social anxiety—are highly prevalent. This reality underscores the complex nature of these anxiety disorders. As such, effective recovery mechanisms must address not only social anxiety, social phobia, and social anxiety disorder, but also the multiple related conditions that often coexist. When recovery methods are discussed for one of these conditions, they are intended to apply to all three.
Here is the general list of emotional and behavioral symptoms of social anxiety disorder (social phobia) from the Mayo Clinic.
Fear of situations in which you may be judged negatively.
Worry about embarrassing or humiliating yourself.
Intense fear of interacting or talking with strangers.
Fear that others will notice that you look anxious.
Fear of physical symptoms that may cause you embarrassment, such as blushing, sweating, trembling, or having a shaky voice.
Avoidance of doing things or speaking to people out of fear of embarrassment.
Avoidance of situations where you might be the center of attention.
Anxiety in anticipation of a feared activity or event.
Intense fear or anxiety during social situations.
Analyzing your performance and identifying flaws in your interactions after a social situation.
The expectation of the worst possible consequences from a negative experience during a social situation.
“Dr. Mullen is doing impressive work helping the world. He is the pioneer of proactive neuroplasticity utilizing DRNI – deliberate, repetitive, neural information.” – WeVoice (Madrid, Málaga)
Analyzing Symptoms from a Personal Perspective
What do these symptoms really mean on a personal level? First, not all of us experience the same symptoms to the same degree. Also, it’s important to understand that social anxiety includes both social and performance anxiety, and some of us are more affected by one than the other.
YOU HAVE INTENSE FEAR OR ANXIETY DURING SOCIAL SITUATIONS
You’re extremely nervous, sometimes to the point of nausea, during social situations. It’s scary and hard for you to be around other people, especially strangers. You do not know how to start conversations and avoid small groups because you fear being ignored or rejected. You fear criticism and judgment. And you feel out of place and alone, and this makes you feel physically and socially undesirable.
YOU FEEL LIKE YOU’RE UNDER A MICROSCOPE
Everyone appears to be watching you and evaluating your actions. No matter where you are, you worry about your appearance and behavior. You are obsessed with how you perceive others see you. Your SAD brain is irrational and biased. So, your hypersensitivity to evaluation, criticism, and rejection makes you see things in a negative light.
YOU FEEL ANXIETY AHEAD OF A SITUATION
You obsess over upcoming social and performance events. And you worry weeks in advance, fearing a bad outcome. And you focus on your perceived flaws. You imagine everything that could go wrong. Worry creates more anxiety, forming a cycle. Your fears of negative judgment or being ignored become so intense that you can become physically ill, looking for any excuse to avoid the situation.
YOU HAVE STRONG FEAR OR ANXIETY DURING PERFORMANCE SITUATIONS
You find it hard to assert yourself in meetings or class. Even speaking up sounds frightening. Why? Because when you perform in front of an audience, you fear negative judgment from peers. If you have to give a presentation, you go through all the fears that come with any social encounter.” Will my hands shake?” “Will my voice tremble?” “Will people take me seriously?”
YOU EXPECT THE WORST POSSIBLE OUTCOMES
… from a negative social experience. If you make a mistake, say something wrong, or show weakness, you blow it out of proportion and then worry about the entire situation. You may even imagine things will go wrong, and the night will end in disaster. Your negative expectations influence your behavior, often leading to the very negative outcome you fear.
YOU OVERANALYZE YOUR PERFORMANCE
You obsess over perceived flaws and mistakes. And you replay conversations and interactions, dissecting every detail. And you spend hours or days reliving the event, rewriting every moment you think you underperformed or appeared awkward. These thoughts only increase your feelings of failure and defeat.
YOU FEEL ALIENATED AND ALONE
You think you don’t fit in because no one understands you. The more you think this way, the more isolated you become from friends and family. You hide or refuse to share your condition because nobody understands what you’re going through. Many therapists aren’t properly trained to diagnose this, and only a few reputable therapy groups exist worldwide.
YOU WORRY ABOUT EMBARRASSING OR HUMILIATING YOURSELF
When you try to socialize, you fear your awkwardness will show. You worry about saying the wrong thing or appearing ignorant. You fear others will mock you. Your attempts at conversation may be clumsy, your small talk awkward, and your attempts at humor poorly received. Your body language may betray your nervousness. And your hands might tremble or your legs shake. You find it hard to look people in the eye, and you may retreat when interactions become too much.
“It is one of the best investments I have made in myself, and I will continue to improve and benefit from it for the rest of my life.” – Nick P.
YOU FEAR BEING THE CENTER OF ATTENTION
Being put on the spot or in the spotlight is a key sign of social anxiety disorder. Because you expect criticism and rejection, you live in constant anxiety, fearing situations like dating, job interviews, and classroom presentations. Even simple activities—like eating in front of others, riding a bus, or using a public bathroom—cause stress. You seek invisibility, hoping not to be asked to participate. If possible, you avoid social and performance settings completely and stay in the safety of your home.
YOU WORRY THAT OTHERS WILL NOTICE YOUR ANXIETY
You’re afraid you’ll show obvious physical signs that could embarrass you. You worry others will see you blushing, sweating, trembling, shaking hands, or other symptoms like nausea, heart race, dizziness, muscle tension, mental blocks, or forgetfulness.
YOU FEEL HELPLESS AND HOPELESS
You’re caught in a cycle that keeps you from living a “normal” life. You feel your options are limited. Because you avoid everyday activities, you feel trapped. You often feel helpless and powerless. You realize your thoughts and actions aren’t always rational, but you feel unable to change. And you don’t know how to break the cycle, and changing habits seems impossible.
YOU HAVE INTENSE FEAR OF TALKING OR INTERACTING WITH STRANGERS
You feel embarrassed, inadequate, or awkward around others. And you avoid these situations because of fear of criticism and rejection. This fear keeps you from gaining social experience. When you do engage, your negative body language—like avoiding eye contact, fidgeting, mumbling—reflects your nervousness, which is a large part of how others interpret you.
YOU FEEL WORTHLESS
You’ve tried everything to get rid of your social anxiety, and nothing seems to have worked.
WHY IS YOUR SUPPORT SO NECESSARY AND ESSENTIAL? ReChanneling develops and implements programs to (1) mitigate symptoms of social anxiety and related conditions and (2) pursue personal goals and objectives – harnessing our intrinsic aptitude for extraordinary living. Our paradigmatic approach targets the personality through empathy, collaboration, and program integration utilizing neuroscience and psychology including proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral modification, positive psychology, and techniques designed to regenerate self-esteem. All donations support scholarships for groups and workshops.
INDIVIDUAL RECOVERY. The symptoms of social anxiety make it challenging for some to participate in a collective workshop. Dr. Mullen works one-on-one with a select group of individuals uneasy in a group setting. ReChanneling offers scholarships to accommodate the costs. What is missed in group activities is provided in our monthly, no-cost Graduate Recovery Group. In this supportive community, graduates interact with others who have completed the program. Contact ‘rmullenphd@gmail.com’.
Committing to recovery is one of the hardest things you will ever do. It takes enormous courage and the realization that you are of value, consequential, and deserving of happiness.
The distinction between social anxiety and social anxiety disorder is in severity. We are not all affected by the same symptoms or relentlessness. The characteristics and traits are equivalent. These conditions originate homogeneously, their trajectories differentiated by environment, experience, and the diversity of human thought and behavior. While comorbidities dramatically benefit, the recovery methods identified are for social anxiety and social anxiety disorder, and reference to one includes the other.
Complementarity
Understanding the holistic nature of our being is a journey into the intricate web of our mind, body, spirit, and emotions – the components of our behavior. These elements of our human holism are not separate entities, but intimately interconnected, each influencing and shaping the others. This interconnectedness is the essence of our emotional well-being.
Defining Our Behavioral Components
It’s easy to provide basic definitions for mind, body, and emotions. Many of us confuse the term ‘spirit’ due to its association with religion and spirituality. In the context of recovery, ‘spirit’ refers to our ongoing emotional state or disposition that influences our perceptions, thoughts, and behaviors.
Emotions versus Spirit
Emotions are temporary outbursts or subjective responses to people, situations, and objects that trigger strong feelings and behavioral responses. Unlike emotions, which are typically intense and short-lived reactions to specific triggers, our spirit is a more enduring emotional state or disposition that is influenced by our fundamental, rigid beliefs.
These beliefs set the tone for interpreting and responding to the world around us, making our spirit a key aspect of our holistic health.
Complementarity refers to the interconnectedness and mutual influence of our behavioral components: mind, body, spirit, and emotions. Understanding this concept can equip us with the knowledge to manage stress effectively.
How does complementarity work? During a fear situation, something triggers us. A trigger refers to a thing, person, or event that elicits a reaction due to its association with some past trauma. This trigger or stimulus alerts our mind, body, spirit, and emotions simultaneously.
Dr. Mullen is doing impressive work helping the world. He is the pioneer of proactive neuroplasticity, utilizing DRNI – deliberate, repetitive, neural information. – WeVoice (Madrid, Málaga)
Trauma Defined
Trauma can be a scary and misunderstood term. It refers to any disturbing experience that results in disruptive or discomforting feelings intense enough to have a long-lasting adverse effect on our optimal functioning. These unsettling events activate the amygdala, which responds by sending out an alarm to multiple body systems to prepare for defense.
Mutual Interaction of Our Behavior Components
Let me provide a hypothetical example. During a fear situation, such as a social event, a trigger might generate automatic negative thoughts such as “No one will talk to me” or “I’ll do something stupid” (Mind). We express these thoughts through our reactions and responses (Emotions). We feel stress and other physical discomfort (Body). And we feel incompetent and inferior (Spirit).
This simultaneous mutual interaction is an example of complementarity in action.
Complementarity reflects the enduring interconnectedness of our four behavior components: mind, body, spirit, and emotions. Connection is the essence of mental health; disconnection is a sign of brokenness.
Utilizing Complementarity
How do we use complementarity to our advantage? We rechannel our anxiety or stress from one component to another. It’s crucial to recognize that we always have avenues of release for any form of discomfort. This awareness prepares us to manage stress effectively.
Through complementarity, we redirect unmanageable emotions – intense and overwhelming feelings that can disrupt our mental and emotional well-being – through physical activity, mental distractions, or spiritual contemplation. We engage in ‘B’ (physical activity), ‘C’ (mental distractions), or ‘D’ (mood reframing) to mitigate ‘A’ (the unmanageable emotion).
Examples of Complementarity
We walk to calm our angst, meditate when agitated, or solve a crossword puzzle to counter anxiety. If the component under stress is physical (such as palpitations, nausea, or tremors), we focus on a mental, emotional, or dispositional (spirit) state to compensate. If it is mental, we focus on a physical, emotional, or dispositional state.
Our mind, body, spirit, and emotions are not isolated entities, but interconnected. They act jointly, each influencing the other, although not always in equal measure. Depending on the situation and subjective response, one component takes precedence over the others.
It is one of the best investments I have made in myself, and I will continue to improve and benefit from it for the rest of my life. – Nick P.
Consider the aftermath of a freeway fender-bender. Our brain becomes chaotic with competing thoughts. Physically, we experience discomfort, if not whiplash. We’re emotionally angry and frustrated and suddenly aware of our mortality.
If we are in pain, the physical likely takes precedence. If we are slightly inebriated, it might be the mental (can I talk my way out of it?), it might be the emotional fear of being arrested, or it might be the dispositional sense of futility.
Managing Complementarity
There are various techniques we learn in recovery to help us redirect our stress. Cognitive reframing, a powerful tool in CBT, enables us to identify our anxiety triggers and gain control over our perspective. For example, if a social event triggers feelings of inadequacy, we can reframe it as an opportunity to improve our social skills, thereby boosting our confidence.
Grounding is a practical coping strategy that involves redirecting situational anxiety by intentionally focusing on the objects, sounds, smells, tastes, and sensations around us. Other methods include using distractions and diversions, focusing on character and persona to change our perspective, and controlled breathing to shift energy by stimulating our vagus nerve.
As we journey through recovery, we gain the power to consciously manipulate our mind, body, spirit, and emotions to our advantage. This enables us to redirect or reframe the anxiety that threatens our emotional well-being. In a broader sense, we take control of our reactions and responses rather than allowing our condition to dominate our thoughts and behavior.
WHY IS YOUR SUPPORT SO NECESSARY AND ESSENTIAL?ReChanneling develops and conducts programs to alleviate the symptoms of social anxiety and help individuals tap into their innate potential for extraordinary living. Our unique approach focuses on understanding personality through empathy and collaboration, integrating neuroscience and psychology. This includes proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral modification, positive psychology, and techniques designed to reclaim and rebuild self-esteem. Every contribution, no matter the size, supports individuals striving to make a positive change in their own lives and the lives of others. All donations go towards scholarships for groups and workshops.
INDIVIDUAL RECOVERY. The symptoms of social anxiety make it challenging for some to participate in a collective workshop. Dr. Mullen works one-on-one with a select group of individuals uneasy in a group setting. ReChanneling offers scholarships to accommodate the costs. What is absent in group activities is provided in our monthly Graduate Recovery Group. In this supportive community, graduates interact with others who have completed the program. Contact ‘rmullenphd@gmail.com’.
Committing to recovery is one of the hardest things you will ever do. It takes enormous courage and the realization that you are of value, consequential, and deserving of happiness.
My book on social anxiety is in the editing phase. I have been fortunate to be included in Springer’s latest volume on Love, due this spring (“Social Anxiety’s Failure to Establish, Develop, and Maintain Healthy Relationships”).
Now, it is time to get back on the road. Unfortunately, my recent speaking engagements and monthly discussions have been online, which does not satisfy the booking agencies.
I am currently looking for more speaking engagements. I am particularly interested in presenting at a conference or seminar. If anyone has contacts with organizations seeking speakers on neuroplasticity, recovery from social anxiety, or the other related topics listed below, please let me know. (“rmullenphd@gmail.com”.)
Compensation or stipend is secondary to having the event taped for future work, as it allows me to reach a wider audience and continue my advocacy for mental health.
As always, I am honored by your encouragement and support.
Speaking Engagements
Speaker Workshop Facilitator Author Educator
Director ReChanneling Inc Social Anxiety & Related Conditions
Keynote and WorkshopTopic
Identifying and Alleviating Social Anxiety’s Impact on Productivity and Leadership
How My Recovery from Debilitating Social Anxiety Can Help You JumpStart Your Career
How Neuroplasticity Can Dramatically Alleviate Your Social Anxiety
Related Topics Reclaiming Self-Esteem Overcoming Social Anxiety and Depression Regulating and Replacing Negative Emotions
My mission is to empower you to rediscover your inherent potential, power, and resilience.
Abstract
Statistics tell us that two out of ten people experience anxiety, and half of those suffer from social anxiety. This can manifest in various ways, such as avoiding social situations, feeling constantly judged, or experiencing doubt and confusion. Seventy percent of those also have depression, and far too many turn to substance abuse. In the fast-paced and demanding world of academia and business, these conditions can lead to missed opportunities, decreased performance, and a lack of motivation to thrive in the workplace and classroom. In the words of Aaron Beck, the pioneer of cognitive-behavioral therapy, we feel helpless, hopeless, and worthless.
Our ability to deliberately accelerate and consolidate learning by compelling our brain to repattern its neural circuitry is a powerful tool for change. We possess the inherent power to transform our thoughts and behaviors. We can deliberately compel our brain to repattern its neural circuitry, empowering us to lead a more fulfilling and balanced life.
As someone who has experienced the hardship of social anxiety disorder for the first half of my life, I understand the toll it can take. I was trapped in its vicious cycle of fear and anxiety, restricted from living a ‘normal’ life. My fear of disapproval and rejection compelled me to avoid the life-affirming experiences that connect us with others and the world.
I have spent the last twenty years researching recovery methods and fusing them into workshops, lectures, and publications worldwide. I discovered how to resolve the adverse self-appraisal that disrupts a life of productivity and prosperity. I’m passionate about helping individuals reclaim their strengths, virtues, and achievements and unlock their full potential.
In my speeches and workshops, I share practical strategies and insights for overcoming the doubts and fears of social anxiety to create a mindset of resilience and potential. Drawing upon my own experiences and teachings, I demonstrate how the deliberate, repetitive input (DRNI) of positive information, which involves consistently exposing ourselves to our positive and affirming strengths and abilities, offsets the negative polarity of our neural network caused by adverse core and intermediate beliefs.
Complementary mechanisms replace our negative thoughts and behaviors with healthy, productive ones and regenerate our self-esteem by rediscovering and reinvesting our character assets.
Understanding neuroplasticity, the brain’s continuous adaptation and restructuring to experience and information, is empowering. It’s what makes learning and registering new experiences possible. Our neural network is dynamic and malleable – realigning its pathways and rebuilding its circuits in response to stimuli. This knowledge gives us the power to control our inner narrative and rewrite the story of our lives.
Through my workshops and coaching programs, I empower individuals to recognize that their weaknesses and failures do not define them. Their character strengths, virtues, attributes, and achievements make them the best they can be. Understanding and appreciating this is a powerful source of motivation and self-worth.
A coalescence of neuroscience and psychology captures the diversity of human thought and experience. Through interactive exercises and group discussions, participants learn practical techniques for managing their thoughts and emotions, building resilience, and cultivating a growth mindset. They discover that they can control their inner narrative and rewrite the story of their lives.
Whether you’re a student, organizer, or professional striving to excel in your field or a potential leader blocked by self-doubt and uncertainty, my keynote speech and workshops can help you recognize your inherent abilities and limitless potential. Together, we can reframe the negativity of your life into a future filled with confidence, resilience, and success.
The pioneer of proactive and active neuroplasticity utilizing the deliberate, repetitive neural input (DRNI) of information.
Former playwright and equity actor in more than a dozen productions. “… outstanding with commanding and polished stage presence” (Hollywood Reporter). Ties to Jimmy Burrows (Frasier, Friends), John Cleese, Mike Frankovich (producer), Gordon Jenkins (Sinatra’s arranger), Sal Mineo, Tennessee Williams …
Co-wrote musical, Ward 22 with Michael Dare (John Belushi’s “Captain Preemo”). Debuted at Jerome Lawrence’s home (Mame, Inherit the Wind).
Wrote/directed LA production of A Country Musical.
Project manager, then European contract negotiator for British Telecom and AT&T
Authored multiple academic articles on social anxiety, depression, and recovery featured in 84 countries.
Publicist to Edith Eva Eger (holocaust survivor) New York Times and Sunday Times bestseller; featured in primetime CBS special, Hitler and Stalin
Treatment advisor and producer’s representative at the Cannes Film Festival 1989
Presenter over sixty virtual discussions on social anxiety, depression, and empowerment
200,000 readers of weekly posted articles on ReChanneling.org website and social media
About Dr. Robert F. Mullen
For over thirty years, Robert Mullen navigated the challenges of severe social anxiety. Often referred to as the neglected anxiety disorder, SAD was a new, underrated, misunderstood, and frequently misdiagnosed condition. Bewildered, angry, and depressed, Robert was a social pariah convinced there was something wrong with him, experiencing first-hand the controlling, devious, and manipulative nature of his disorder.
In his mid-forties, Robert Mullen returned to university, challenging SAD’s grip on his emotional well-being. It was a journey of trial and error, but the answers eventually revealed themselves. He now dedicates his career to the millions of people worldwide who struggle with anxiety and depression. His commitment to this cause is a beacon of hope for many.
Before his pivotal decision, Robert’s career was a tapestry of diverse experiences. He spent several years as an equity actor and playwright in Hollywood, with minor roles in TV and film. He was a publicist and manager for artists and writers, including Auschwitz survivor and New York Times bestselling author Dr. Edith Eva Eger. His journey also led him to serve as a film project treatment advisor and representative at the prestigious Cannes Film Festival.
Moving to the San Francisco Bay Area, Robert ran his own artists’ management company before becoming an international contract negotiator for AT&T and British Telecom.
It was at university that Robert honed his talents in public speaking for a variety of organizations. Post-doctorate, he created the nonprofit group ReChanneling, which develops and implements programs to (1) mitigate symptoms of social anxiety and related conditions and (2) pursue personal goals and objectives – harnessing our intrinsic aptitude for extraordinary living.
Robert’s work has not just made a mark, but a profound impact in the field of mental health. He has published numerous articles and chapters and produced a YouTube series on recovery. He is credited as the pioneer of proactive neuroplasticity, a technique supported by the deliberate, repetitive neural input (DRNI) of information. This approach has been instrumental in developing workshops, lectures, and seminars that have helped hundreds of clients.
Robert’s paradigmatic approach targets the personality through empathy, collaboration, and program integration. It utilizes neuroscience and psychology techniques designed to replace or overwhelm negative thoughts and behaviors with healthy, productive ones, while producing rapid, concentrated positive stimulation to offset the abundance of negative information in our brains’ metabolism.
Dr. Robert Mullen teaches clients mindfulness (recognition, comprehension, and acceptance) of their inherent capabilities and potential. To be the best we can be, we must not define ourselves by our deficits and shortfalls but by our character strengths, virtues, attributes, and achievements.
I’ve been there… I’ve experienced the despair of social anxiety and its network of fear and avoidance of human connection.
I had no courage, no self-esteem, no purpose.
No one understood my condition.
I created an innovative method of recovery and rediscovered my potential and defined my purpose:
To share my experiences and expertise with those who continue to suffer.
Speaking engagements include:
American Academy of Religion – Atlanta/Berkeley/Phoenix American River College, Sacramento Asian Studies on the Pacific Coast, Portland University British Telecom, San Bruno, CA Bunnings Group Limited, AUS (SF Convention) The Exchange for the Performing Arts, Sacramento First Unitarian Universalist Society of San Francisco Folsom Lake College, CA Lakeshore Unitarian Society, Winnetka, IL Six+ years of Monthly Online Discussions on Social Anxiety Marshall Hospital, Placerville, CA Sacramento AIDS Foundation San Francisco Media Alliance Scottish Rites Temple, Los Angeles Society for Asian & Comparative Philosophy, Monterey
Social Anxiety Disorder
The distinction between social anxiety disorder and social anxiety is a matter of severity; reference to one includes the other. The recovery tools and techniques provided apply to comorbid emotional malfunctions, including depression, substance abuse, generalized anxiety, and issues of self-esteem and motivation. These malfunctions originate homogeneously, their trajectories differentiated by environment, experience, and the diversity of human thought and behavior.
Fear of situations in which you may be judged negatively
Worry about embarrassing or humiliating yourself
Intense fear of interacting or talking with strangers
Fear that others will notice that you look anxious
Fear of physical symptoms that may cause you embarrassment, such as blushing, sweating, trembling or having a shaky voice
Avoidance of doing things or speaking to people out of fear of embarrassment
Avoidance of situations where you might be the center of attention
Anxiety in anticipation of a feared activity or event
Intense fear or anxiety during social situations
Analysis of your performance and identification of flaws in your interactions after a social situation
Expectation of the worst possible consequences from a negative experience during a social situation – (Mayo Clinic)
Testimonials
Mullen is the pioneer of proactive neuroplasticity utilizing DRNI ‒ deliberate, repetitive, neural information. – WeVoice (Madrid, Málaga, Valencia)
It is refreshing to work with an organization that possesses sincere commitment, ethics, and genuinely cares about its clients. – Sharon Hoery & Associates, Colorado
It is one of the best investments I have made in myself, and I will continue to improve and benefit from it for the rest of my life. – Nick P.
I have never encountered such an efficient professional … His work transpires dedication, care, and love for what he does. – Jose Garcia Silva, PhD(composer Cosmos)
Social Anxiety Workshop produced results within a few sessions, with continuing improvement throughout the workshop and beyond. I’m now much more at ease in situations that were major sources of anxiety and avoidance for me just a few months ago. – Liz D.
A leading expert on social anxiety disorder and its comorbidities, Dr. Mullen is the father of proactive neuroplasticity. – Lake Shore Unitarian Society, Winnetka, IL
Dr. Mullen is considered a leading expert on anxiety and depression, etc. If you want to regain your sense of self-worth and confidence, you may want to consider recovery. It’s a bit of work but well worth the effort. – Matty S.
I am simply in awe at the writing, your insights, your deep knowing of transcendence, your intuitive understanding of psychic-physical pain, your connection of the pain to healing, your concept/title, and above all, your innate compassion. – Janice Parker, PhD
Publications
2025. Social Anxiety’s Failure to Establish, Develop, and Maintain Healthy RelationshipsinC.-E. Mayer, E. Vanderheiden Handbook of Love, Part 2. Springer
If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained, you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle. ̶ Sun Tzu
Knowing Social Anxiety
Few had heard of social anxiety before 1994. When I returned to university in my late forties, recovery methods were still in their formative stages and, as I later discovered, poorly invested in social anxiety. Even today, experts treat our condition like any other emotional malfunction when it is anything but. Social anxiety, nicknamed the ‘neglected anxiety disorder,‘ presents unique challenges through its cunning ability to make recovery approaches – productive for most disorders – woefully inefficient for those in our condition.
Although it was apparent to me early on that conventional treatment options for social anxiety were ineffective, the reasons were unclear. After much research and personal application, I embarked on a journey of comprehending how social anxiety sustains itself. I discovered that the mysteries of social anxiety, like the sacred Eleusinian sect of ancient Greece, only reveal themselves to the initiated.
In other words, only someone who has walked in our shoes and defeated the oppression of social anxiety can effectively guide you through recovery. Conventional recovery methods, while clinically sound and well-intentioned, are unreliable at best.
“Dr. Mullen is doing impressive work helping the world. He is the pioneer of proactive neuroplasticity utilizing DRNI – deliberate, repetitive, neural information.” – WeVoice (Madrid, Málaga)
What is Social Anxiety?
Social Anxiety Disorder (SAD) is a multifaceted and intricate health condition. In the forward to these posts, I emphasize that the distinction between social anxiety, and the DSM-identified social anxiety disorder is not just a matter of severity; it’s a complex interplay of various factors. As any expert will attest, there are subtle differences. However, the recovery process, sans medication, is individually focused and remains strikingly similar.
SAD is a formidable opponent, a master of disguise that withholds its secrets from those who haven’t experienced its enigmatic and catastrophic nature. It is more mysterious than a hormonal teenager, and deciphering its enigmatic structure is challenging, but together we can methodically unravel its mysteries.
SAD steals our identity, making us feel unwelcome and exposed in social situations because we feel unworthy. The condition crushes our self-esteem, causing us to doubt our worth and abilities. It saps our motivation, causing us to avoid activities and personal connectivity. SAD does not want us to be happy because that takes away its power. It does not want us to know how it operates. It does not want to release us from its insidious grasp.
SAD is the fearful boogeyman who can only be excised by the bright, exposing light of rationality.
SAD makes us feel helpless and hopeless, trapped in a vicious cycle of fear and anxiety, and restricted from living a ‘normal’ life. Our fear of disapproval is so severe we avoid the life-affirming experiences that connect us with others and the world. We fear the unknown and unexplored. We endure anxiety for weeks before a situation, anticipating the worst. And we worry about how others perceive us and how we express ourselves.
SAD is like one of those movies in which aliens invade our bodies. They feed off our misery and hopelessness, thriving off our fears and anxieties. The only thing that can kill them is identifying and overwhelming them with rational mindfulness. We starve them with positivity and self-awareness, causing them to wither and die.
“It is one of the best investments I have made in myself, and I will continue to improve and benefit from it for the rest of my life.” – Nick P.
Two Keys to Understanding Social Anxiety
What is Sun Tzu telling us in this post’s opening quote? To effectively challenge our condition, we must know exactly what we are confronting and how it affects us individually. This knowledge empowers us to appreciate the caliber of its weaponry and fashion superior ones, putting us in control of our recovery.
Knowing the ‘Enemy’
Knowing how our social anxiety controls and manipulates us is one key to recovery. Recognizing the symptoms and characteristics of our condition provides the wherewithal to overwhelm and defeat them.
One of the biggest impediments to recovery is our unwillingness to accept or disclose our condition. Many of us deliberately choose to remain ignorant of SAD’s destructive capabilities or go to enormous lengths to remain oblivious to them, as if, by ignoring them, they do not exist or will somehow go away.
It’s astonishing how many clients, after enduring SAD for their entire lives, choose to remain clueless about the easily identifiable symptoms listed by every reputable mental health institute.
The Symptoms
So, let’s put an end to our ignorance once and for all by identifying the common characteristics of social anxiety disorder.
We fear situations in which we may be judged negatively
We worry about embarrassing or humiliating ourselves.
We have an intense fear of interacting or talking with strangers.
We fear that others will notice that we look anxious.
We fear revealing physical symptoms that may cause us embarrassment, such as blushing, sweating, trembling, or a shaky voice.
We avoid doing things or speaking to people out of fear of embarrassment.
We avoid situations where we fear being the center of attention.
We express anxiety in anticipation of a feared activity or event.
We have intense fear or anxiety during social situations.
We negatively analyze our performance and focus on our faulty interactions after a social situation.
We expect or self-prophesize the worst possible consequences from a negative experience during a social situation.
So, no more excuses. We now have a basic understanding of the common symptoms of our condition. Social anxiety instills in us unsound fears and apprehensions that are disproportionate to the actual situation. Social anxiety steals our autonomy, hopes, and dreams. It crushes our expectations and possibilities, causing us to miss opportunities to connect with the world. We beat ourselves up for our perceived defects and inadequacies. SAD convinces us that we are undesirable and worthless.
Knowing Ourselves
The other equally important key to recovery is understanding how we are adversely affected by SAD. Because we are unique individuals with diverse experiences, environments, beliefs, needs, and aspirations, these challenges are highly subjective and differ with each individual.
While occasional anxiety is a normal part of life, those of us with SAD experience it in a different, more intense way. We tend to personalize and dramatize our anxiety. Often blowing it out of proportion and obsessing over its potential negative outcomes. This can lead to self-fulfilling prophecies where we inadvertently encourage our failures.
Living with SAD means dealing with persistent anxiety and fear in everyday situations. Even simple tasks like eating in front of others, riding a bus, or using a public restroom can become unduly stressful. We often find ourselves seeking invisibility, hoping to avoid any situation that might require us to participate. As Matty S. shared in our workshop, ‘I spent high school trying to hide in every dark corner with a book in my face. I never once ate lunch in four years, and never once went to the bathroom in four years at my high school, for fear of having to interact with people.’
Living with SAD means navigating a paradoxical emotional landscape. We often find ourselves craving companionship while shunning intimacy, fearing that we will be deemed unlikeable. It’s not fear that destroys our lives, but the avoidance strategies we develop to cope with it. At the peak of my anxiety, I would circle the block repeatedly before a social situation to bolster my courage. Often, I ended up in the bar across the street rather than the event, a clear example of how I anticipated and guaranteed my self-loathing through avoidance.
Our social interactions are often clumsy, small talk inelegant, and attempts at humor embarrassing. Our anticipation of repudiation motivates us to dismiss overtures to offset any possibility of rejection. SAD is repressive and intractable, imposing self-destructive thoughts and behaviors. It establishes its authority through defeatist measures produced by distorted and unsound interpretations of reality.
Sharing our experiences with social anxiety is like describing an alien disease – a solitary and fruitless endeavor, as others struggle to comprehend what is only understandable to the person afflicted. The comprehensible lack of empathy further isolates us as we face the challenges of our condition alone, highlighting the struggle and need for understanding our complex relationship with our condition.
The journey to self-discovery and overcoming anxiety is a gradual process that requires patience, introspection, and persistence. What makes us tick? What triggers our fears and apprehensions? Where do we feel anxious or fearful? What activities are we engaged in, and what thoughts arise? How do we feel (physically, intellectually, emotionally, spiritually)? What specific concerns or worries do we have? What is the worst thing that could happen? And what do we imagine might occur? Who, where, or what do we avoid due to these feelings?
Once we have a healthy understanding of SAD and how it personally affects us, we will have met Sun Tzu’s criteria for fearlessness in facing the many battles that lie ahead.
WHY IS YOUR SUPPORT SO NECESSARY AND ESSENTIAL? ReChanneling develops and implements programs to (1) mitigate symptoms of social anxiety and related conditions and (2) pursue personal goals and objectives – harnessing our intrinsic aptitude for extraordinary living. Our paradigmatic approach targets the personality through empathy, collaboration, and program integration utilizing neuroscience and psychology, including proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral modification, positive psychology, and techniques designed to regenerate self-esteem. No matter the size, every contribution supports someone striving to make a difference in their lives and those of others. All donations support scholarships for groups and workshops.
Committing to recovery is one of the hardest things you will ever do. It takes enormous courage and the realization that you are of value, consequential, and deserving of happiness.
I was recently chatting with Stephanie from Singing Gecko on one of her posts. And she mentioned my comment was Stoic and optimistic and I absolutely loved that. But before I go into this story, I want to take a minute to shoutout Stephanie. She is such a cool person. Her posts really make me think and she has an awesome vibe. Do check out her blog. Okay, now back to how Stoicism saved my mental health.
Basically her comment reminded me that I am in fact a Stoic and have practised Stoicism for years now. I first learnt about it in my first year of university when I took a philosophy course. It really stood out to me because it was the first time I had heard a philosophical school of thought that perfectly encompassed my own beliefs. And the more I read about it, the more I agreed with what I was reading.
Over time, I began to include Stoic practices in my life and saw a major shift in my mental health. But first, let’s talk about Stoicism. I’m sure most people that know are interested in philosophy or know basic philosophical schools will be familiar with Stoicism. But for those that may not be, I’ve shared a little bit about Stoicism and a Wikipedia link if you would like to read more about it.
What Is Stoicism?
“Stoicism is a school of Hellenistic philosophy that flourished in Ancient Greece and Ancient Rome. The Stoics believed that the practice of virtue is enough to achieve eudaimonia: a well-lived life. The Stoics identified the path to achieving it with a life spent practicing the four cardinal virtues in everyday life — prudence, fortitude, temperance, and justice — as well as living in accordance with nature. It was founded in the ancient Agora of Athens by Zeno of Citium around 300 BCE.
Alongside Aristotle’s ethics, the Stoic tradition forms one of the major founding approaches to virtue ethics. The Stoics are especially known for teaching that “virtue is the only good” for human beings, and that external things, such as health, wealth, and pleasure, are not good or bad in themselves (adiaphora) but have value as “material for virtue to act upon”.
Many Stoics—such as Seneca and Epictetus—emphasized that because “virtue is sufficient for happiness”, a sage would be emotionally resilient to misfortune. The Stoics also believed that certain destructive emotions resulted from errors of judgment, and people should aim to maintain a will (called prohairesis) that is “in accordance with nature”. Because of this, the Stoics thought the best indication of an individual’s philosophy was not what a person said but how the person behaved.
To live a good life, one had to understand the rules of the natural order since they believed everything was rooted in nature.” (Source: Wikipedia)
How Stoicism Saved My Mental Health
So, now that you have a better understanding of Stoicism we can get into how Stoicism saved my mental health and has pretty much changed my life over the last few years. For those of you that don’t know, I was diagnosed with depression and anxiety as a teenager. So that’s what I’ll be referencing throughout the post. Anyway, this is how Stoicism saved my mental health:
Acceptance
One major aspect of Stoicism is that Stoics believe that we have free will but also that there are things out of our control. Basically, we believe in destiny, that things are pre-determined. However, how we choose to perceive things is up to us. Realising this was a giant game changer for me.
Growing up, I was always someone that needed control. I like things to be perfect, everything has its place. When things don’t go exactly as planned and even if there’s a slight hitch I would go into absolute anxiety mode. However, I have become so much more calm now when things don’t go as planned. Of course, I’m not perfect at it and I don’t think perfection is achievable. But I accept things that come my way. I experience the negative emotions associated with it and then I process and let them go. I don’t let it debilitate me.
This has been a huge game-changer for my anxiety. I’m no longer meticulously plan every tiny aspect of my life because I’m terrified I’ll do something wrong if I don’t. Can you imagine how exhausting it was for me to be doing that before? But no more. Now, I let life do its thing because I understand that being on anxiety mode 24/7 is not going to change my destiny. But how I choose to react will. I control what I can and I accept what I can’t
Stoic Exercises/Practices
There are a number of Stoic practices that those that believe in Stoicism try to include into their life. Today, I want to talk about two that I practice that have helped me so much with my mental health.
The first one is negative visualisation. This is a technique where you periodically imagine losing the things you value (like your job, health, or loved ones). I know, this sounds super grim and trust me it’s not for everyone. But hear me out. This made my life so much easier and decreased my anxiety immensely. I used to be so anxious all the time about bad things happening. Losing people I love, losing my health, not doing well in school, losing clients etc. But this practice has helped me picture the worst again and again until it’s no longer as anxiety inducing for me. I have finally come to terms with the fact that it’s a part of life that sometimes we do lose things we value. But we can’t let that stop us, we have to stay strong and keep going even when we hit rock bottom.
Another practice that I have added to my routine is voluntary discomfort. Stoics often engage in practices that voluntarily make life harder to build resilience and remind themselves that discomfort is not inherently bad. Earlier, when my anxiety was at its worst any sort of discomfort would ruin my day and I would shy away from it. I realised that this was actually a trauma response.
For me, voluntary discomfort is about doing social things because that makes me very uncomfortable. A few years ago, even leaving the house would give me anxiety. Now, I go out all the time. Sometimes on my own just to have a relaxing mental health day. I’m no longer scared to dine alone, shop alone, talk to new people. Things that would have petrified me have now become enjoyable.
Courage
This was a big one for me and one that was a major trigger for my depression. I’ve always been one of those people that are extremely sensitive to fighting or confrontation. That’s a huge trigger for my PTSD. But I’m also someone that takes their morals and ethics really seriously. When someone does something I believe is wrong or harming someone else, I feel unsettled. But I would never confront people about their behaviour before. Especially narcissists. Now, I’m not longer afraid of confrontation. I still avoid it when I can but when I need to say something, I do it.
Acting in accordance with virtue, even in the face of adversity is an important part of Stoicism. And it’s what taught me to stand up for myself and those that couldn’t stand up for themselves. I’m really proud of how far I’ve come. And thanks to no longer bottling everything up and setting healthy boundaries, my depression and anxiety have gotten so much better. Instead of being depressed that the world sucks, I can now stand up and fight for things to get better.
Moderation and Neutrality
Exercising moderation in all things and avoiding excess is another things I learnt from Stoicism. I used to see things as very black and white before I began actively practicing Stoicism. And that was a really depressing way to see the world. It made me very pessimistic and unhappy.
Now, I understand that things are much more complex. Nothing is black and white, most things are grey. Which is why it’s important to try to stay neutral and objective. Don’t get to a place where you’re on an unrealistic extreme.
As for moderation, I think I’ve generally been a pretty moderate person but over time I have become much less materialistic. I was never that materialistic but I did like occasionally to splurge on things I was interested in like books, skincare, makeup etc. Now, I put a lot more importance on people and memories instead of stuff.
The Bigger Picture
One thing I did a lot of reading and reflecting about is living according to nature. For Stoics, this means understanding the natural world and our place within it. It involves recognising that life is unpredictable and transient. Change is a constant part of it. And that is why it’s so important to learn to accept that and be prepared instead of holding on to the past.
Figuring out my place in the world also helped me recognise just how insignificant I am. Which again, I know sounds a little depressing but it wasn’t for me. It had the opposite effect. I was no longer insecure about those little flaws I saw in the mirror, about my weight, my hair, my body. Because none of that mattered and most people probably didn’t even notice or care about those things. I was just a tiny part of a big world. This did wonders for my social anxiety.
Constant Growth
Wisdom and understanding what is truly important in life is one of the cornerstones of Stoicism. Stoics often practice mindfulness and reflection. Regularly reflecting on your thoughts, actions, and responses helps Stoics become more self-aware. This practice encourages us to examine our judgments and adjust them to align with virtue.
I’ve talked about meditation, mindfulness and reflection quite a lot in my mental health related posts so I won’t go into too much detail again on this one. The post has already become so much longer than I expected it to be. But basically, reflecting on my day and trying to be a better version of myself each day has helped me immensely with my mental health. It’s helped me understand myself and those around me. And most importantly, it’s helped me become a better person which in turn makes me a lot more confident than I used to be. I know what I stand for and don’t look to others to define me.
Final Thoughts
That’s how Stoicism saved my mental health and helped me be the person I’ve become today. I hope you enjoyed this post. I don’t talk about my philosophical beliefs much because I feel like people wouldn’t care too much or would maybe not find that interesting. People that love philosophy love it but those that don’t really don’t. But since a lot of my readers do enjoy my mental health related posts, I thought this would be interesting to them. And maybe a different perspective because I don’t see many people talking about Stoicism in relation to mental health. But for me the two are interrelated and it was important for me to tell my story of how Stoicism saved my mental health.
Disclaimer: If you or someone you love are experiencing mental health problems please talk to a professional or someone you trust. Please seek help if you feel that it is necessary. There is absolutely nothing wrong with needing help.
Lifesfinewhine, a timely and popular website, is a beacon of hope for those navigating mental health issues. Its producer, P.J. Gudka, was diagnosed with depression and generalized anxiety as a teenager. Through research and self-reflection, she has gained a profound understanding of mental health illnesses and the stigma that often surrounds them. Her latest book, All the Words I Kept Inside, is a transformative collection of poetry that encourages readers to delve deep within themselves and confront their darkest thoughts. It takes the inner dread, disappointment, and heartache we all experience and reveals the words of the heart, inspiring hope and transformation.
If you have a story or perspective to share, we encourage you to submit a post for ReChanneling’s website. Please contact rmullenphd@gmail.com to learn more about the submission process.
Unable to cope with fear and uncertainty, a person resorts to denial, repression, compromise, and hides behind the mask of a false self. ― Kilroy J. Oldster, Dead Todd Scrolls
Defense Mechanisms
Understanding and applying coping mechanisms can significantly empower us to alleviate stress and reduce the release of fear and anxiety-inducing hormones. Recovery-oriented coping mechanisms, such as distractions and projecting positive outcomes, give us a sense of control when confronting fearful situations.
Maladaptive coping mechanisms, which we all use at some point, are known as defense mechanisms. These are temporary strategies we unconsciously employ to handle triggers our minds are unequipped to manage.
Defense mechanisms are mostly unconscious and automatic safeguards against stressful situations—psychological reactions designed to protect us from trauma. Although these psychological responses defend us from our fears and anxieties, they are not long-term solutions.
Examples of such mechanisms include denial, conversion, projection, and repression.
Without coping mechanisms, defensive or otherwise, we can experiencedecompensation – the inability to generate effective psychological coping mechanisms in response to stress – resulting in personality disturbance or disintegration.
The difference between defense and coping mechanisms is that the latter are adaptive and promote emotional well-being and recovery. For instance, avoiding a social situation due to fear of criticism and rejection would be considered a defense mechanism, while confronting the feared situation by employing positive self-talk, mindfulness, and social skills training is adopting coping mechanisms.
It is important to remember that although coping and defense mechanisms do not address the root causes of our fears and anxieties, they can provide limited emotional relief. Like an analgesic that temporarily alleviates physical pain, these mechanisms can positively influence our emotional well-being and help rebuild our self-esteem as we navigate our mental health journey. However, it’s crucial to understand and address the root causes.
“It is one of the best investments I have made in myself, and I will continue to improve and benefit from it for the rest of my life.” – Nick P.
Notwithstanding their label, many defense mechanisms support recovery when utilized appropriately. Some, like avoidance, humor,and isolation, need no explanation. Others, such as compensation and dissociation, have positive values in recovery when employed appropriately.
Compensation is when we overachieve in one area of our lives to offset perceived failures in another. For example, a poor student may become a star athlete. We compensate for our negative thoughts and behaviors by channeling our efforts into healthy, productive accomplishments. This process helps rebuild our self-esteem as we focus on our strengths, virtues, and attributes rather than the aspects of ourselves affected by social anxiety.
In essence, we leverage our best qualities to counteract any perceived deficits in self-esteem caused by our social anxiety.
“Dr. Mullen is doing impressive work helping the world. He is the pioneer of proactive neuroplasticity utilizing DRNI – deliberate, repetitive, neural information.” – WeVoice (Madrid, Málaga)
Dissociation
In psychological terms, dissociation refers to the experience of detaching from reality. Dissociation can range from mild emotional detachment to more significant disconnection from physical and emotional trauma. Dissociation helps people manage their emotional well-being by separating their thoughts, memories, feelings, and actions from distressing situation(s).
In less severe cases, we might dissociate by daydreaming or losing ourselves in a good book or movie, which can temporarily relieve stress.
In recovery, we practice deliberate dissociation from the symptoms of social anxiety. This act allows us to separate ourselves from the negative aspects of our condition to focus on our character assets. It provides a sense of control and confidence to objectively analyze our thoughts and behaviors to respond rationally and productively.
When our identity remains intertwined with social anxiety, consciously dissociating from the symptoms of our condition is a functional and productive approach.
Dissociation
Dissociation helps us recognize that we are not defined by our condition’s adversities but rather by our resilience, assets, and determination. It is a deliberate act rather than the unconscious responses linked to our automatic negative thoughts (ANTs).
Theoretically, when we disassociate, parts of our brain become more active and others less active. To regenerate our self-esteem, we energize the positive aspects of our character over the adverse self-appraisal of our condition.
For those who dispute my use of dissociation as frivolous, substitute the words disconnect, separate, uncouple, disunite, or liberate.
When we remain entangled with our social anxiety disorder, we often see ourselves as helpless, hopeless, undesirable, and worthless. These core and intermediate beliefs, shaped by childhood experiences and reinforced by our condition, become the nemesis of our self-appraisal.
By dissociating from social anxiety, we step away from self-targeting to objectively analyze our irrational thoughts and behaviors, leading to more rational and productive responses.
This shift from a disease model to a wellness model is significant. The disease model focuses on the problem, while the wellness model—rooted in humanistic and positive psychologies—emphasizes the solution. It defines health as physical, mental, and social well-being rather than merely the absence of disease or infirmity. This change in perspective fosters optimism for our recovery and reveals opportunities and possibilities.
It’s important to remember that we are not our social anxiety; we are individuals experiencing social anxiety. We do not identify as the injured limb when we break our leg. We view it as something that requires healing. The same principle applies to our recovery from social anxiety. Dissociation is not a sign of weakness; it is a tool we use to distance ourselves from our condition and take proactive steps toward healing.
WHY IS YOUR SUPPORT SO NECESSARY AND ESSENTIAL? ReChanneling develops and implements programs to (1) mitigate symptoms of social anxiety and related conditions and (2) pursue personal goals and objectives – harnessing our intrinsic aptitude for extraordinary living. Our paradigmatic approach targets the personality through empathy, collaboration, and program integration utilizing neuroscience and psychology, including proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral modification, positive psychology, and techniques designed to regenerate self-esteem. No matter the size, every contribution supports someone striving to make a difference in their lives and those of others. All donations support scholarships for groups and workshops.
INDIVIDUAL RECOVERY. The symptoms of social anxiety make it challenging for some to participate in a collective workshop. Dr. Mullen works one-on-one with a select group of individuals uneasy in a group setting. ReChanneling offers scholarships to accommodate the costs. What is missed in group activities is provided in our monthly, no-cost Graduate Recovery Group. In this supportive community, graduates interact with others who have completed the program. Contact ‘rmullenphd@gmail.com’.
Committing to recovery is one of the hardest things you will ever do. It takes enormous courage and the realization that you are of value, consequential, and deserving of happiness.
Maybe the journey isn’t so much about becoming anything. Maybe it is about un-becoming everything that isn’t really you, so you can be who you were meant to be in the first place. – Paul Coelho
Our character comprises the mental, emotional, and moral qualities distinctive to our individuality. Traditional psychology and its extensions use the term “character” to refer to our patterns of behavioral traits such as passive-aggressive, narcissistic, anal, hysterical, borderline, and so on. The pathographic or disease model of mental healthcare, the modus operandi for centuries, continues to be the overriding psychological perspective, focusing on the biological and neurological origins of mental illness, i.e., the study of the origins of our harmful behaviors.
The wellness model, a pivotal concept in early positive psychology (1998-), shifted the focus from the pathography of mental illness to the healthy aspects of behavior – our character strengths, virtues, and attributes. It emphasized that character is not just a collection of traits but a dynamic expression of positive thoughts, feelings, and behaviors that underscore our emotional, mental, and moral character.
Positive psychology 2.0, a corrective evolution, embraced both positive and negative aspects of our character, recognizing the dialectical opposition of human experience. It proposed that optimal human functioning is not just about positivity but about living a balanced and meaningful life, engaging fully with our positive and negative aspects.
The next and current wave of positive psychology (3.0) broadened the scope of research and practice beyond the individual to include relationships, groups, organizations, and societies – how our character and values reflect and contribute to the community to which we belong, influence, and are influenced.
“Dr. Mullen is doing impressive work helping the world. He is the pioneer of proactive neuroplasticity utilizing DRNI – deliberate, repetitive, neural information.” – WeVoice (Madrid, Málaga)
Character Strengths, Virtues, and Attributes
Positive psychology identifies 24 character strengths universally recognized for creating individual stability and resilience. These strengths are not just traits, but powerful tools that can empower us to overcome challenges and lead a fulfilling life.
These strengths are classified into six distinct virtues: wisdom, courage, humanity, justice, temperance, and transcendence.
Positive attributes refer to behavioral moralities contributing to our character and emotional well-being.
Recovery Goal and Objectives
The primary goal of recovery from social anxiety and related conditions is the alleviation of our irrational fears and anxieties. We execute these goals through a three-pronged, complementary approach.
Replace or overwhelm our negative thoughts and behaviors with healthy, productive ones.
Produce rapid, concentrated positive stimulation to offset the abundance of negative information in our brain’s metabolism.
Regenerate our self-esteem through positive reinforcement and mindfulness of our assets, utilizing methods targeted toward our individuality.
From childhood disturbance to our current emotional status, social anxiety has inundated our neural network with adverse stimuli through negative core and intermediate beliefs, SAD symptomatology, and cognitive biases, leading to destructive, irrational thoughts and behaviors. We call this SAD’s negative trajectory. Our brain’s current metabolism is replete with abundant negative information.
Why Create a Character Resumé?
Childhood disturbances generate negative core beliefs that influence our intermediate attitudes, rules, and assumptions. Our attitudes refer to our emotions, convictions, and behaviors. Rules are the principles or regulations that affect our behaviors, and assumptions are what we believe is accurate and authentic information.
Maladaptive attributions produce a cognitive bias that compels us to misinterpret information and make self-destructive decisions. Since humans are hard-wired with a negativity bias, we already respond favorably to adversity. Add our SAD-induced negative trajectory, and our neural network is replete with toxic information.
We convey this through our thoughts and behaviors and the words we use to express them.
Adversity consumes and conditions us throughout our lives. According to reliable sources, we have heard the word “no” from our parents roughly 135,000 times by age sixteen. Some of us use the same unfortunate characterizations repeatedly. It is not just the words we say aloud in criticism and conversations. The self-annihilating words we silently call ourselves support our adverse thoughts and behaviors.
A character resumé, a tool created and expanded during treatment, manages the three significant recovery objectives. It is a document that lists our positive qualities, achievements, and memories as reminders of our strengths and capabilities. Through introspection and memory work, we become mindful of the qualities that social anxiety’s overwhelming negativity has subverted.
This renewed awareness aids in replacing and offsetting our negative thoughts and behaviors with healthy, productive ones. Through proactive neuroplasticity, they become a vital component of the repetitive input of positive information into our neural network. Additionally, mindfulness and reinforcement of these assets dramatically regenerate our self-esteem.
Replace
Our goal is not just to replace or offset our adverse thoughts and behaviors but to empower ourselves with healthy, productive ones. We construct our character resuméwith positive qualities, achievements, and memories to counter the abundance of negative self-beliefs acquired throughout life.
We retrieve and become mindful of them through recovery approaches, e.g., personal introspection and inventory, memory work, cognitive comprehension, and other tools and techniques. This process requires determination and commitment, but the rewards are immense.
Restructure
Proactive neuroplasticity is a powerful tool that produces rapid neurological stimulation to change the polarity of our neural network through the deliberate, repetitive neural input (DRNI) of information. In simpler terms, it’s the process of intentionally rewiring our brain by repeatedly exposing it to positive information.
Our brain receives around two million bits of data per second but processes roughly 126 bits, so providing substantial positive information, which we can pull from our character resumé, is essential.
A deliberate act is premeditated; we initiate and control the process. Repetition accelerates and consolidates neural renewal and connectivity. Sound, reasonable, goal-focused, and unconditional information determines its strength and integrity. The positive traits we include in our character resumé generate the most efficient words and statements to accelerate and consolidate the process of neural restructuring.
Regenerate
Regeneration is the process of renewing or restoring something damaged or underproduced. Due to our negative self-analysis, we tend to repress, misplace, and forget our inherent and developed assets. These self-qualities (e.g., confidence, reliance, compassion, and other self-hyphenates) are damaged but not lost.
Despite the disruptions in our optimal development, the qualities that establish our self-esteem are not lost. They may be latent or dormant but can be developed and restored. Disruption interrupts productivity, but it does not destroy it.
Like stimulating the unexercised muscles in our arms or legs, our self-esteem can be regenerated.
“It is one of the best investments I have made in myself, and I will continue to improve and benefit from it for the rest of my life.” – Nick P.
Supports Multiple Learning Styles
Learning styles are the methods clients use to understand and retain information. Creating a carefully crafted character resumé that identifies our positive qualities and achievements satisfies multiple learning styles and increases awareness and retention. A character resumé supports auditory learning through the repetition of positive neural input, visual learning through patterns and colors, verbal learning through the written word, logical learning through the patterns and logic of the outline, and linguistic learning through reading, writing, and listening.
Positive Psychology in Recovery
Positive psychology (1.0), which focuses on character strengths, virtues, and attributes, is a powerful tool in recovery. By recognizing and emphasizing our positive aspects, we counter the abundance of neural negativity and adverse self-appraisal.
When extended, positive psychology’s 24-character strengths provide a diverse array of attributes that can empower the client, shifting the focus from negative to positive. This shift is not just a change, it’s an inspiration, a motivation to embrace our potential and worth.
PP 2.0 and PP 3.0 are essential recovery components but do not directly contribute to our character resumé. However, they factor strongly in the evolution of our recovery.
Positive Psychology 2.0
Recovery is not just about recognizing our strengths, virtues, attributes, and achievements. It’s also about acknowledging our shortcomings. This balanced perspective is critical to repairing our brokenness and moving forward.
Notwithstanding, due to decades of negative self-appraisal perpetrated by social anxiety, our neural network is already grossly imbalanced by negativity, and we are already abundantly aware of our flaws and deficiencies, real and perceptual.
Additionally, recovery is based on identifying the irrational fears and anxieties that perpetuate our thoughts and behaviors and establish our automatic negative thoughts (ANTs). PP 2.0 equips us with the tools to navigate these challenges.
Positive Psychology 3.0
Positive psychology 3.0broadened the scope of research and practice beyond the individual to include relationships, groups, communities, organizations, and societies – how we contribute to the community.
Self-esteem, a crucial aspect of our recovery, is the awareness of our qualities and character, including our imperfections. It encompasses our self-perception, our perception of how others view us, and how we process this information. A healthy level of self-esteem reassures us of our worth and significance.
Our renewed awareness leads to self-compassion and self-appreciation. As we recognize our unique contributions, we are inspired and motivated to share them with others. Interconnectedness is a natural and significant progression of self-esteem, fostering a sense of caring and empathy.
Positive psychology plays a significant role in our recovery journey. It’s not just about self-care but about understanding our worth and potential and championing these self-beliefs in others. This moral evolution is a natural development of recovery, and positive psychology is a critical player in this process.
Method Integration
It’s crucial to understand that positive psychology is just one component of an effective recovery program. A comprehensive plan includes closely related programs such as cognitive-behavioral therapy, active and proactive neuroplasticity, recovery-oriented cognitive therapy, schema therapy, cognitive-behavioral modification, acceptance and commitment therapy, rational emotional behavior therapy, and gradual exposure therapy. Recognizing the role of positive psychology in this comprehensive context underscores the effectiveness of a well-rounded recovery plan.
Elements of a Character Resumé
What goes into our character resumé? The answer is anything and everything that stimulates a positive personal response. The character resumé is not a static document but an evolving, living entity. Entries can include our rediscovered character strengths, virtues, and attributes; positive personal affirmations; positive autobiography; rational responses to our automatic negative thoughts (ANTs), happy memories; things we enjoy; and self-esteem self-analysis or other self-esteem inventories.
Positive Personal Affirmations. PPAs are self-motivating and empowering statements that help us focus on goals, challenge negative, self-defeating beliefs, and reprogram our subconscious minds. Providing all the neural benefits of positive reinforcement, PPAs self-describe who and what we aspire to in our emotional development.
PPAs are rational, reasonable, possible, positive, unconditional, problem-focused, brief, and first-person present or future time. Think of PPA’s as aspirations or self-fulfilling prophecies that, through deliberate repetition, help replace our abundance of negative with positive neural information. Practicing positive personal affirmations is a highly effective form of deliberate, repetitive neural input of information.
Positive Autobiography. Our positive autobiography helps regenerate mindfulness of our successes, achievements, contributions, personal milestones, talents, charitable deeds, and service to others. Mindfully retrieving these positive events and occasions encourages us to recognize and embrace the extraordinariness of our lives, confirming that we are valuable, desirable, consequential, and worthy of all the good things life offers.
Rational Coping Statements are the logical, self-affirming responses to our situational fears, anxieties, and automatic negative thoughts. Example: If we fear rejection in a social situation, rational responses might be, “I belong here as much as anyone.” “I am valuable and significant.” “I am equal to anyone here.” “My fear is irrational.” We execute rational responses through the following process.
Identify our Feared Situation. Where are we when we feel anxious or fearful, and what activities are involved? What are we thinking? What might we be doing? Who and what impacts these insecure feelings?
Identify our Associated Fear(s). One way to identify our fears (anxieties) is to ask ourselves: What is problematic about the situation? How do I feel (physically, intellectually, emotionally, spiritually)? What is my specific concern or worry? What is the worst thing that could happen to me? What do I imagine will happen to me?
Unmask our Corresponding ANTs. How do we express our fear or anxiety? What are our involuntary emotional expressions or images? How do we negatively self-label? What do we tell ourselves? “I am incompetent.” “I am stupid.” “I am undesirable.”
Examine and Analyze Our Fear(s) and ANTs. What are the origins of our fears and anxieties? How do we express them? Discovery approaches include cognitive comprehension, introspection, psychoeducation, and the vertical arrow technique.
Generate Rational Coping Statements. We become mindful of the irrationality and self-destructive nature of our associated fears, anxieties, and corresponding ANTs. We unmask, examine, and analyze the cognitive distortions and maladaptive that validate or reinforce them. Then, we devise rational responses to counter their false assumptions.
Happy Memories and Things We Enjoy. These two subjective lists are developed and expanded throughout the recovery program as introspection and other positive recovery methods reclaim them from the recesses of our minds. Due to our cognitive biases and distortions, we forget the pride, joy, and satisfaction these events and experiences bring to our thoughts, behaviors, and positive patterns within our neural network. Happy memories and joyful experiences are potent forces in regenerating our self-esteem.
Self-Esteen Self-Analysis. There are a plethora of clinically approved self-esteem inventories and scales, including, but hardly limited to, the Coopersmith Self-Esteem Inventory (CSEI), Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSE), and Sorenson Self-Esteem Test.
One that we utilize as a valuable element of our character resumé is called Self-Esteem Self-Analysis, a subjective evaluation that encourages introspection and self-awareness, helping us identify what we like about ourselves mentally, emotionally, physically, spiritually, and socially.
In Conclusion
A written record of our achievements and strengths is a powerful tool for self-reflection and self-improvement, helping us stay organized and in control of our personal development.
When challenged by negative self-appraisal or automatic negative thoughts, our character resumé constantly reminds us of our qualities and assets—a written evaluation of our value and significance. This indispensable resource helps alleviate self-destructive thoughts, behaviors, and other adverse self-beliefs.
WHY IS YOUR SUPPORT SO NECESSARY AND ESSENTIAL? ReChanneling develops and implements programs to (1) mitigate symptoms of social anxiety and related conditions and (2) pursue personal goals and objectives – harnessing our intrinsic aptitude for extraordinary living. Our paradigmatic approach targets the personality through empathy, collaboration, and program integration utilizing neuroscience and psychology, including proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral modification, positive psychology, and techniques designed to regenerate self-esteem. All donations support scholarships for groups and workshops.
INDIVIDUAL RECOVERY. The symptoms of social anxiety make it challenging for some to participate in a collective workshop. Dr. Mullen works one-on-one with a select group of individuals uneasy in a group setting. ReChanneling offers scholarships to accommodate the costs. What is missed in group activities is provided in our monthly, no-cost Graduate Recovery Group. In this supportive community, graduates interact with others who have completed the program. Contact ‘rmullenphd@gmail.com’.
Committing to recovery is one of the hardest things you will ever do. It takes enormous courage and the realization that you are of value, consequential, and deserving of happiness.
Today, I wanted to share my Blogger Interview with Robert F. Mullen, the latest episode of my podcast. I’ve known him for a really long time thanks to blogging and I have really admired the work he does. As you will notice if you decide to visit his site, he has a doctorate and his area of expertise is social anxiety.
In this interview, we talk about so many things but in particular we focused on mental health and social anxiety. These topics are actually quite personal to me because I’ve been suffering from both depression and social anxiety since I was a teenager. And as he mentions in the interview, these two disorders often go hand in hand.
Robert F. Mullen’s approach is quite different from what I have seen, read and heard about social anxiety. And since he was someone who once suffered from social anxiety himself, I think he has a really accurate idea of what it’s like. He views recovery from social anxiety as “a collaboration of science, philosophy, and psychology” and believes that therefore its remedy must be thought of in the same way.
And from my own experiences with social anxiety, I can’t help but agree. When it comes to research about mental health, I find that it’s always from a specific lens. It focuses on science or psychology or other aspects. But the truth is, for a lot of people at least, it’s a combination of everything that causes the disorder.
If this sort of content sounds interesting to you, check out our interview below. And don’t forget to check out his site. It’s truly a mine of information.
* * *
Lifesfinewhine, a pioneering international website from Kenya, offers invaluable insights into mental health issues. The site’s producer, Pooja G, was diagnosed with depression and social anxiety as a teenager. Her journey, marked by rigorous research and deep self-reflection, has given her a profound understanding of mental health illnesses and the stigma that often surrounds them.
* * *
Comments
“Another very interesting and informative interview. I was particularly uplifted, by the fact that he went through so many transitions in life, before finding his true calling. I admire his approach to his practice. His clients… his life.” – byngnigel
“Another great interview. I love how he is for the underdog.” – Joseph Glidden
“That was a wonderful interview! I am also someone who suffers from social anxiety, thanks for all the work you do Robert!” – Carol anne
”Great interview with Robert Mullen… I love his approach coming from his own background and passing it on to support others.” – Cindy Georgakas
What is your truth? What is your secret? What secrets are you keeping from the world that you hope one day you will be brave enough to tell? When will you tell your heart? All The Words I Kept Inside allows you this moment.
This collection of poetry urges you to look deeply inside and confront your darkest thoughts. It takes that inner dread, disappointment, and heartache to reveal the words of the heart. This book will show you that you are not alone. That you are understood. That you don’t have to go through these dark moments on your own because so many of us experience them too. The words found inside will reach out a hand and guide you. Amazon Books
WHY IS YOUR SUPPORT SO NECESSARY AND ESSENTIAL?ReChanneling develops and conducts programs to alleviate the symptoms of social anxiety and help individuals tap into their innate potential for extraordinary living. Our unique approach focuses on understanding personality through empathy and collaboration, integrating neuroscience and psychology. This includes proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral modification, positive psychology, and techniques designed to reclaim and rebuild self-esteem. Every contribution, no matter the size, supports individuals striving to make a positive change in their own lives and the lives of others. All donations go towards scholarships for groups and workshops.
Committing to recovery is one of the hardest things you will ever do. It takes enormous courage and the realization that you are of value, consequential, and deserving of happiness.
This is not a typical posting on recovery from SAD and related conditions but a published chapter on a psychological method called psychobiography. While admittedly pedantic, it explains how psychobiography, a form of character study, assists in knowing the individual in recovery. More on psychobiography is available on this website at Broadening the Parameters of the Psychobiography and Utilizing Psychobiography to Moderate Symptoms of SAD.
Abstractions of Intent: How a Psychobiography Grapples with the Fluidity of Truth
in C-H. Mayer and Z. Kovary (eds.) (2019). New Trends in Psychobiography, Springer; 1st ed, pp. 539. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-16953-4
Robert F Mullen, PhD
Abstract: A psychobiography is a well-researched, comprehensive, multi-method presentation of a series of occasions through the documentation of events and the explication of the causes, motivations, and consequences thereof. In the fashion of Whitehead, occasions are dynamic and ongoing activities unfolding or producing themselves through time. The creative events that precipitate―originating, anchoring, and turning points―are fixed in time as opposed to the unfixed spatial-temporal reality of an occasion. The psychobiography uses both qualitative and quantitative methods of analysis because of their interactive objective and subjective contributions. The psychological aspect of the qualitative system allows for the in-depth case study, which presupposes that the issues under investigation are best understood from a perspective inclusive of the subject’s personal, subjective and phenomenological world. The quantitative study utilizes verifiable occurrences and statistics to determine the validity of interpretation.
An accompanying facet of a carefully crafted psychobiography is the hermeneutic circle, another component susceptible to error due to the varying definitions and understandings that accompany all manner of texts. These potentials for misinformation are aggravated by the researcher who is susceptible to (1) incorporating personal sensibilities, (2) bias and misinterpretation due to the nature of the investigation, (3) the suggestiveness of the subject and (4) the researchers own condition. A psychobiographical study is also subject to misinformation revealed by the subject, sources, and contemporaries. Awareness of these potential impediments to veracity is essential; however, the researcher cannot allow the search for truth to overwhelm the authenticity of the product.
Adopting multiple strategies can provide a more comprehensive overview of a subject, whose diverse aspirations and plentiful activities warrant a broader exploration. A consequence of the mixed methodology, however, are the opportunities for misrepresentation that result from the adoption of vulnerable systems, especially in the psychological realm which solicits speculation, inference, and other subjective calculations.
In May 1886, Georges Seurat unveiled his 70 square foot Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grand. The painting depicts fashionable Parisians enjoying a Sunday afternoon on an idyllic island in the River Seine between Neuilly and Levallois-Perret. The canvas is replete with some forty stereotypical Parisian figures―women of fashion, men in bowler hats, prostitutes, children, umbrellas, dogs, soldiers, boats, a rowing team, a monkey, and a musician.
Individually, the rigid and somewhat indistinguishable images are ill-designed to be the focus of singular attraction but are integral and essential to the panorama. The technique Seurat adopted, Pointillism, involved the use of small touches of pure color intricately placed side-by-side on the canvas. When viewed from a certain distance, these colored spots blend into figures of aesthetic clarity. Move closer, and the portraits dissipate, rendering the composition unintelligible. Move away, and each part asserts its relevance to the whole, but the whole is not its parts, and the parts do not constitute the whole.
The painting, viewed from afar as intended, is a gestalt: the whole is other than the sum of its parts, albeit dependent upon their participation. The individual figures and the finished work resonate in codependence with one another, manifesting a masterpiece abstractly detached from the components that constitute the work. The truth of Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grand is in the exactness of the colored spots, their placement on the canvas, and the changeless final masterpiece which the artist deemed worthy of display.
In an abstract sense, the similarities between this artistic masterpiece and a psychobiography are appealing. The methodology incorporates seemingly inconspicuous elements of a life history that, when placed side-by-side on an academic canvas, blend into events and occasions that are, by themselves, imperceptible to the final product. Step back to observe the multiple entities rendered by this method. And one begins to sense their integral relationship to the cohesive whole of the presentation. One only needs canvas, the painted background (the subject’s ethos), and figures, pronounced and ambiguous (entities and occasions), assembled by numerous points of color (causes and consequences) that coalesce into an integral and homeostatic final product.
Understanding Events and Occasions
Every evolution―ethos, philosophy, activity, and so on―is an occasion. Occasions are akin to Alfred North Whitehead’s actual entities. Defined as dynamic and ongoing activities unfolding or producing themselves through time (Hosinski 1993). The events that participate in the creative unfolding of an occasion are fixed in time as opposed to the unfixed spatio-temporal process of an occasion. A psychobiography is a well-researched, comprehensive, multi-method presentation of a series of occasions through the documentation of events and the explication of the causes, motivations, and consequences thereof.
Pillemer (1998) suggests three significant or seminal episodes central to a psychobiography. Originating events are the momentous events that are responsive to the genesis of a subject’s enduring beliefs or attitudes. Anchoring events represent the milestones that perpetuate these values, as evidenced by the subject’s life-story. The third episodes, turning points, mark specific series of events and occasions that augment the subject’s passion. This triumvirate of causal relationships is not a one-off. But is integral in the evolution of all substantial beliefs and activities.
Throughout this chapter, a published study developed and produced employing a psychobiographic methodology is exampled. The overarching focus of the study is a contemporary theorist with diverse aspirations and activities. Convinced that the sheer volume of life occasions merited multiple avenues of investigation, a mixed-message methodology of both quantitative and qualitative research was adopted. Personal philosophy bore significantly on the relevance of abundance. A scholar grasping a singular view denies the creative capacity that flourishes in the enlightened awareness of human ingenuity.
The errant belief that there is only one truth and that any one individual is in possession of it is the root of all malevolence that plagues the world. A theorist of any mettle studies systems and embraces a collective. Any theory or philosophy is based, intentionally or unwittingly, on an amalgam of grounding belief systems. In any theory, the tenets that form its ground are particular, relative, and essential constituents; their axiomatic completeness equal to (or other than) the sum of values and beliefs. One cannot be a rationalist without experientialism, logic, and discursive reasoning. Utilitarianism needs the participation of reductionism and forms of naturalism.
Michael Murphy is co-founder and Director Emeritus of Esalen, nestled in California’s Big Sur. The progressive Institute is the acknowledged birthplace of the human potential movement (Tompkins 1976), inspired by Abraham Maslow’s psychology of peak experiences, which underscores humanity’s potential for the metanormal expansion of consciousness.
Murphy’s search for meaning―and his exploration of wide-ranging and diverse fields to validate that search―underscores multifaceted constituents that support his philosophy and productivity much like pointillism colors its canvas. At least four philosophical components undergird Murphy’s world vision and activities: existentialism, experientialism, humanism, and universal integrality. Murphy’s research into and conviction of deliberate human advancement― heralding a higher complexity of human consciousness―is underscored by these fundamental philosophical concepts, which required extensive study rendered by multiple available means. A mixed-methodology of quantitative and qualitative research proved optimal.
However, the permissiveness afforded by a psychobiography―its hermeneutics, its in-depth case study, narrative, etcetera―lends itself to error and misinformation. The relevance of this theme reveals itself throughout this chapter.
A psychobiography differs from a simple mixed-methodology in scope and magnitude. The use of multivalent systems in the Murphy study ensured an integrally comprehensive presentation. The end-product was not without its faults, however. Upon publication, the validity of certain conclusions became questionable to the researcher.
Was the result true to the subject’s values and contributions? Was the justification of his belief system well defined? And was his integrity underscored in the conclusions? How are truth and authenticity best served and what impediments require accommodation? How does the truth factor in a psychobiography as opposed to other methods of inquiry? Does the broad scope of a psychobiography deliver more forthright conclusions than other, less inclusive methods?
The attractiveness of the broad and inclusive multivalent methodology is due to the number of available options, tolerance of structural fluidity, and the contemporary inclination to adopt and adapt to the latest, cutting-edge methodology. Abundance, however, is a distraction that demands judicious evaluation and editing to avoid superfluous corroboration and unnecessary explication in a study already comprehensively substantive. A psychobiography is not an all-you-can-eat-buffet but a system that offers multiple options which necessitate good choice, careful determination of value and moderation: attributes of most established writers but difficult to grasp for the novice academic.
“It is one of the best investments I have made in myself, and I will continue to improve and benefit from it for the rest of my life.” – Nick P.
What is a Psychobiography?
Simply defined, a biography is an account of someone’s life written by someone other than the subject. According to William McKinley Runyan (1984, 36), a biography is “a portrait painted by a specific author from a particular perspective, using a range of conceptual tools and available data.” Barclay Erickson (203, 35) quotes historian R. G. Collingwood (1946) from The Idea of History, who defines biography as “the discerning of the thought which is the inner side of an event.” Biographical narratives foster a keen understanding of characteristic adaptations, a concept coined by Northwestern psychologist Dan McAdams (2001, 126), to include:
such personal goals and motives, defense mechanisms and coping strategies, mental representations of self and others, values and beliefs … domain-specific skills and interests, and other personal characteristics contextualized in the time, place, or social role.
The psychology in a psychobiographic study inserts itself through aggregate-level social sciences such as social structure and personality interpretation, history, sociology, psychological anthropology, and political psychology. The study maintains its flexibility by drawing upon the knowledge of many schools of thought while devising new concepts as they become necessary for evaluation. Extensive and often exhaustive research is required to remain faithful to the subject’s intersubjectivity.
Runyan (1988, 285) advocated for the use of psychology in psychobiography, “mediated through the aggregate-level social sciences, including such scientific ‘substratum’ as social structure and personality, historical sociology, psychological anthropology, and political psychology.” George Atwood and Robert Stolorow (1993, 9) also campaigned for the use of multiple perspectives, promoting “a psychobiographical method capable of flexibly drawing upon the knowledge of all the different schools of thought, and also of devising new concepts as it goes along.”
In the published study exampled throughout, this correlated well with the data-driven research of extraordinary events and occasions which, as Murphy points out in The Future of the Body: Explorations Into the Further Evolution of Human Nature (1992, 2) demands “a synoptic acquisition of soundly verifiable data that draws at once upon the natural and human sciences, psychical research, religious studies, and other fields.”
The methodology of Erik H. Erikson’s (1958) Young Man Luther: A Study in Psychoanalysis and History is the genesis of modern psychobiography and its foundation of psychological analysis. To Atwood and Stolorow (1993, 13), Erikson was the first pure psychobiographer because he was able to synthesize aspects of the psychology of knowledge (personal-subject relativity) and the sociology of knowledge (historical-cultural relativity). “Although each field [psychology of knowledge and sociology of knowledge] can make a certain degree of independent progress, their analyses are allied and complementary.” What evolves from these cooperations are syntheses of material that coalesce into a verifiable, historic narrative. These sciences include sociology, biology, psychology, religion, phenomenology, history, and so on.
Psychoanalytic histories bridge the gulf between the concrete particularity of individual life and the experience of being human in universal terms … providing the initial basis of comparison for describing the pattern of the individual’s life as the realization of shared human possibilities (Atwood & Stolorow 1984, 7).
Murphy’s theoretical constructs emerge from both Eastern and Western spiritual philosophy. He is a barometer of humanity’s temperament, including its mental, physical, and spiritual aspects. The events and occasions of his life are integral to his ethos, worldview, and subsequent activities. These include: (1) research and analysis of philosophical and scientific apperceptions of advanced metanormal potential, 2) data-driven evidence of advanced human potential, (3) efforts to bridge the gaps among science, religion, and mysticism, while identifying the comparability of religious teloi, and (4) humanitarian efforts in education, health, politics, and religion to address the disenfranchised through international diplomacy (Mullen 2014, 175).
The plenitude of Murphy’s contributions made it expedient to employ many investigative approaches; a more restrictive methodology would have failed to adequately accommodate the magnitude. Combining qualitative and quantitative inquiry made it easier to research and document the scope of Murphy’s life, ethos, goals, productivity, and so on. The construction of the whole, the final product, was achieved through a thoughtful and scholastic synthesis into a final gestalt. In hindsight, success was only partial, and conclusions flawed, a complication arising from the ambiguities of truth and the freedom accorded by the use of multiple methodologies.
Quantitative research involves the empirical investigation of observable and measurable variables. It is used for testing theory, predicting and illustrating outcomes, and determining integral relationships. Quantitative research takes a particular approach: answering research questions, generating hypotheses, setting up research strategies, offering conclusions, and so forth. Analysis of data-driven research is quantitative, as are surveys, and comparative or correlational studies. Although generally conceived as focusing on data articulated numerically, Quantitative analysis is also used to study events or magnitudes of occurrence.
Qualitative research focuses on examining topics via cultural phenomena, human behavior, and belief systems. A comprehensive study of the life and productivity of an individual can make use of interviews, open-ended questions, opinion research, and so on to gain insight into certain beliefs, concepts, and systems. It provides an overview of the human side of an issue concerning behaviors, beliefs, opinions, emotions, and relationships, supported by such intangible factors as social norms, esoteric beliefs, ethnicity, socio-economic status, philosophy, religion, ethics, etcetera.
A psychobiography is constructed by engaging qualitative and quantitative methodologies and their subsidiaries―the empirical and non-empirical, ontological and epistemological, narrative, interview, in-depth case study, hermeneutics, the social sciences, and so on. Even so, while this mixed-method study meets the criteria of an adequate psychobiography it, by no means, promises the most comprehensive, which demands a more robust and radical adoption of multivalent ingredients and methods to subsidize the gestalt. The components of a good psychobiography are more fluid, fragmented, and decentralized in its pursuit of authenticity.
The good psychobiography will not shy away from seemingly disparate components but will embrace than as means to provide a more thorough investigation. Resoluteness and flexibility, concreteness and fluidity, proof and conjecture, reason and intuition, exclusion and inclusion―all become academically acceptable grist for the mill. A quantitative approach creates a blueprint that establishes the parameters of the study, a logical order that provides the foundation for the various components necessary to the evolution of the product. The qualitative element, more reflexive and evolving, adds texture and nuance to the structure. The quantitative architecture strategizes the product; the qualitative animates it.
Picture a fan in the stands at a baseball game, seated in one of multiple sections offering an angular and myopic view. To fully appreciate the game, the fan listens to the statistician and color-commentator on the radio, one actor providing hits, runs, and innings, the latter, personality profiles and stories. Awash with the sticky smell of beer and hotdogs, inclement weather, ear-shattering insults and enthusiastic roars, and the mingled sweat of thousands, full appreciation of the game is experienced though the combined components that contribute to the festive totality of the event. Remove a singular sensation―the sound, the smell―and the experience is different. The game is a more dynamic and thorough experience because of the multivalent stimuli―coalescing conflicting forces that converge to narrate nine or more innings.
The Case Study
A psychobiography is an in-depth case study, according to Atwood and Stolorow (1993, 27-28), an integral and comprehensive presentation of a personalistic, phenomenological, historical, clinical, and interpretive investigation. Its methodology allows the gathering of as much information as possible, using multiple disciplines. Three general characteristics distinguish an in-depth psychobiographical case study from other methodological orientations and approaches. First, the in-depth case study is “inherently personalistic and phenomenological because it presupposes that the issues under investigation can are best understood from a perspective inclusive of the subject’s personal, subjective and phenomenological world.” Second, psychobiography is historical, albeit the fluidity of occasions mitigates the opportunity for a purely linear presentation.
Third, the in-depth case study is both “clinical and interpretive.” This overarching requisite for interpretation is a double-edged sword as the researcher is highly susceptible to (1) incorporating his or her sensibilities, (2) bias and misinterpretation due to the vicariousness of biography, (3) the suggestiveness of the subject, and (4) the researchers own condition. Condition is one’s current state-of-being as consequence of reaction and adaptation to experience and circumstance. The study is also subject to bias and misinformation supplied by the subject, sources, and contemporaries. Awareness of these potential impediments is essential; however, the psychobiographer cannot allow the search for truth to overwhelm the authenticity of the work, which implies being genuine or as real as possible.
Case study research allows the exploration and understanding of the motivations, events, and occasions that impact the subject’s life history. This holistic, in-depth investigation specializes in analysis of the subject’s social, moral, ethical, and behavioral underpinnings: schooling, faith instruction, socio-economic status, family structure, and other influencers which motivate sociological concerns. This method was particularly relevant to Murphy’s focus on education, health, religion and other humanitarian efforts.
A good psychobiography is “committed to a narrative mode of truth arrived at through [the] in-depth, case study approach to biographical and psychological knowledge” (Erikson 1958, 39). The case study nourishes itself through intersubjective methodology, which aids in clarifying relationships and motivations. Intersubjectivity is the psychological relationship between people―how common-sense, shared values are used to interpret mutual compliance within social and cultural life. It is the trademark of systems and institutions which share a particular ideology. It also highlights how unilateral groups alienate disagreeable groups through self-preservation, which incurs bias, prejudice, truth-distortion, and other extensions of inherent territorial emphasis. Intersubjective investigation addresses these temperaments, as well as those of others who offer significant support or opposition as evidence of motivation.
Interviews and Review of Materials
Among the sources of data the psychologist is likely to turn to when carrying out a case study are interviews with the subject and contemporaries, diaries, personal notes, letters, documents, and so on. In psychology, case studies often confine themselves to the examination of a particular individual; a psychobiographic researcher is inclined to extend this research to contemporaries and other influencers.
Murphy’s firm conviction of the inherent human potential to access the metanormal required the theoretical study of phenomenon to describe the subjective reality of events, and philosophical research and analysis, which involved clarification of definitions, prevailing wisdom, and norms. The perusal of the books, essays, and articles written about the subject was necessary. Esalen’s (2013, 2014) extensive website was an excellent source of corroboration. Multiple sources about issues and values addressed by Murphy had to be analyzed, as did his published fiction, nonfiction, and works-in-progress.
The interviews were of inestimable value, first to set the boundaries of a good working relationship and then as a forum to address topics that required further explication. These one-on-one interviews, structured by specific lines of questioning, were generously enriched by Murphy’s extemporaneous flow of vision and thought. On average, these meetings lasted approximately two hours. Some issues were explored in person, others via phone and email. Recordings of interviews were professionally transcribed, results reviewed, and submitted to Murphy for approval. The rich material from these interviews informed multiple aspects of the study.
About halfway through the process, however, findings antithetical to the researcher’s secular sensibilities began to manifest. An Actual Man (2010) is a series of essays in honor of Murphy’s 80th birthday. Among the stories and anecdotes were short biographies describing Murphy’s humanitarian works in Russia, and Esalen’s part in Yeltsin’s 1991 ascension to the presidency. Tompkins’ (1976) extensive profile in The New Yorker was a highlight, as was evidence of the metanormal in everyday experience, a tribute by Huston Smith, and Ken Wilber’s encomium to an exemplary human being.
In the midst of these and other profound contributions was a story about Murphy’s paranormal escapades with the San Francisco 49ers. The essay asserted that the ritualistic burying of football gear and Murphy’s ability to manipulate Universal order was instrumental in the 1981 success of the fledgling upstarts that led to their first Superbowl. Numerous texts supporting research into paranormal were analyzed, including Frederic Myer’s (1907, 1918) early 20th-century evidence of levitation and life-after-death and Thurston’s (1951) descriptions of stigmata, luminous phenomena, and bilocation.
Murphy’s penchant for metaphysics and other esoteric practices cornered the psychobiographer into a self-created abyss of intellectual superstition, confirmation of how a researcher is subject to personal bias and singular perception. The football story was omitted from the study for fear it would unduly prejudice readers against the merit of Murphy’s contributions to natural science. The paranormal corroborations of Myers and others of his ilk were minimized for the same reason,
Was that the right choice? In hindsight, these arbitrary exclusions may have slightly repudiated Murphy’s authenticity. Later introspection revealed the story of the 49ers as a tongue-in-cheek, piece of smart fiction or, at the most, an illustration of over-inflated egos. In his forward of Cosmos and the Psyche, Richard Tarnas (2006, xiii) writes:
Skepticism is the chastity of the intellect … The mind that seeks the deepest intellectual fulfillment does not give itself up to every passing idea … Only with that discernment and inward opening can the full participatory engagement unfold that which brings forth new realities and new knowledge.
Murphy has authored and collaborated on numerous novels and works of nonfiction. Incorporated into the study was an assessment of his fiction as evidence of his predilection for mystic spiritualism, Eastern and Western collaborative thought, and metanormal human capacity. Elements of his appreciation for the interrelationship of science, mysticism, and esotericism began in novel form then neatly transcribed themselves to his most crucial nonfiction work: the data-driven research on transformative human capacity, The Future of the Body: Explorations Into the Further Evolution of Human Nature (1992).
A subject’s worldview is both implicit and definitive exposition of philosophical and religious lineage. It was essential to look at the significant contributions influencing Murphy’s evolution of thought―paranormal research, Catholic miracles, esoteric documentation, the evolution of psychology, Huxley, Maslow, and Teilhard de Chardin,cross-cultural religion and metaphysics, process and evolutionary philosophy, science, and so on.
This abundance of research material provided a more formidable and daunting diversity of interests that served as the foundation for study and informed the substratum of Murphy’s ontological development. Mainstream academic research was enlisted to solidify, confirm, or offer alternative viewpoints for the subject’s theories. Murphy (1992, 15) defines this method of data-driven research, analysis, and interpretive documentation as “synoptic, multidisciplinary, or integral empiricism (remembering, of course, that empiricism usually refers to data acquisition and verification limited to sensory experience).”
The Narrative
Embracing individuality within a history of events and occasions is, of course, a key component to any study of a person. The primary method for doing so is through narrative. As personality psychologists begin to turn attention to the subjective nature of peoples’ life histories, the story becomes more valid in “conveying the coherence and the meaning of lives” (McAdams 2001, 102). In a psychobiography, the narration is the method of presentation incorporating the elements relative to the construction of the final product into a stimulating and understandable rendition of the subject’s evolution of thought, and activity.
Storytelling is a method of making the study readable, comprehensive, and appealing. Pillemer (2008) defines narrative truth as the criterion used to decide when a particular experience is captured satisfactorily; it depends on continuity and closure and the extent to which the fit of the pieces takes on an aesthetic finality. It is left to the researcher to determine, through judgment and scholasticism, the primary experiences that factor into decision-making and lend themselves to the subject’s worldview.
In The Rise of Hermeneutics (1972), Dilthey and Jameson caution that ascertaining truth through narrative biography will incite debate, a desirable component of any presentation. To them, narrative truth is a razor’s edge because of the many factors that instigate misinformation. Since narration is a composite of many differing and supporting collegial contributions, this unpredictability is even more prevalent.
One of the more unique qualities of Murphy’s body of written work is the transposition of his fictional accounts of metaphysics, science, the spiritual, the magical, and the mystical to his later nonfiction that complements and enhances the actuality of many conclusions, the plausibility of more, and possibility of the remaining. This evolution originates with his fantastical creations of the metanormal in his best-selling Golf in the Kingdom (1972), continues throughout his other novels, and culminates in his data-driven, natural science exploration The Future of the Body: Explorations Into the Further Evolution of Human Nature (1992).
In other words, Murphy’s concentration in the natural history of metanormal accession and evidence thereof does not diminish in the transition from novel to nonfiction but expands and substantiates itself. It is a textbook example of how, in the words of Cyril “Life imitates Art far more than Art imitates Life, and I feel sure that if you think seriously about it, you will find that it is true” (Wilde, (1909, 10).
Michael Murphy has written or contributed with significant impact to more than half-a-dozen additional works of nonfiction, which address the codification of transformative capacities, the evolution of humanity’s potential, extraordinary capacities within sports, studies of yogis and Zen masters, cardiovascular and metabolic changes, and psychological, physiological, and spiritual transformation.
These are illustrated to corroborate the vast diversity of materials that were considered, and as evidence of how Murphy’s forays into fiction implemented his later works. In an article in The American Society for Aesthetics, F. E. Sparshott (1967, 3) argues against those who contend that works of fiction cannot be considered the embodiment of claims to tell any truth about the real world. Truth in fiction is “the explicit content of the fiction, and a background consisting of either of the facts about our world … or of the beliefs overt in the community of origin.”
The Historical
A singular substance cannot exist without its interrelationship with other substances. Everything, every entity is a creation―intertwined, interconnected, and interdependent with and within other creations. It is therefore prudent to engage Pillemer’s (1998) three significant or seminal events as central to the evolution of occasions. To iterate, it is impossible to provide a purely linear exposition of a subject’s history because of the non-temporal fluidity of occasions.
History is primarily concerned with the knowledge of the mind and the thoughts it generates, which motivate an individual’s philosophy and action. “The task of the historian is penetrating to the thought of the agents whose acts they are studying” Collingwood (1946, 25). The evolution of Murphy’s occasions is paramount to this study, as is his place in contemporary studies of a natural history that combines science with religion and metaphysics. William McKinley Runyan’s (1984) Life Histories: A Field of Inquiry and a Framework for Intervention served as a support vehicle for inquiry into the role of Murphy’s life-history.
Particularly germane were the investigations into: 1) the philosophical growth and conclusions resulting from Murphy’s intensive study, and experiential activities, (2) his ethos and set of mental characteristics, (3) analysis and insight into the psychological motivations of his ethos and activities, and (4) the practical implementation of these motivations and activities in interactions with others. The study provided special consideration to Murphy’s research into human transformative capacity―his conviction of the potential for metanormal functioning as evidenced by his participation in, and investigations into events, occasions, practices, and phenomena affected by and affecting the human person. Dilthey and Jameson (1972, 227) write:
There can indeed be no history worthy of the name that does not breathe something like his spiritual enthusiasm for the traces that life has left behind it, something of the visionary instinct for all the forms of living activity preserved and still instinct within the monuments of the past.
Murphy’s fundamental philosophies staunchly lend themselves to the theory of advanced innate human potential. His existentialism underscores the human faculty to determine its motivation and development, especially essential to its inherent ability to deliberately evolve by way of metanormal events and occasions. His experientialism is manifest by his actual experiments to affect extraordinary events and occasions. Humanism is evident by his belief in involution and evolution, a doctrine that asserts the self-creativity, and self-reliance of each person, imbued by divine allowance and participation.
Finally, universal integrality posits that all entities are creatively bound to all other entities, intertwined, interconnected, and interdependent. It is these systems that motivate the events paramount to Murphy’s occasions. As the theory maintains, occasions are not only evolutionary but interdependent upon all that precedes and proceeds them. One cannot fathom their causes without understanding the relevant factors of the creative process; it is the task of the researcher to make best efforts to investigate and comprehend this process through abundant research and thoughtful explication.
Hermeneutics
The interest in psychobiography slowed between the great wars of the Twentieth Century to witness a resurgence in Dilthey’s (1961) adoption of hermeneutics. The hermeneutic circle is similar to gestalt in that the parts are “accessed in relation to a totality while knowledge of the whole is constituted by study of the parts” (Atwood and Stolorow 1984, 3). The ultimate goal of the hermeneutic process is to discover how the subject’s philosophic, spiritual, and religious subjects of inquiry facilitated his or her ethos and subsequent activities. In Methodology for the Human Sciences: Systems of Inquiry (1983, 221), David Polkinghorne advocates for the use of hermeneutics to better understand what canon and tradition mean to a specific element of philosophy.
Hermeneutics is possible here because … there is here the relation of the parts to the whole in which the parts receive meaning from the whole, and the whole receives meaning from the parts: these categories of interpretation have their correlate in the structural coherence of the organization [and subject], by which it realizes its goal teleologically.
Hermeneutics is a system of rules, “a whole whose parts were held together by the aim of giving an interpretation of general validity” (Dilthey and Jameson 1972, 240). One’s spiritual and philosophical evaluations are products of interconnected parts, which are in turn constituents of the whole; again, the parts without the whole—as well as the whole without its parts—inadequate to conclusive evaluation. Scholars later expanded the system of hermeneutics to apply to any literary text, which broadened the scope of influence on a particular ethos or philosophy while maintaining the integrality of hermeneutic tenets. Polkinghorne (1983, 221) warns that one of the considerations of hermeneutic knowledge is that it is difficult “to attain a degree of intersubjective agreement and certainty that one has understood an expression accurately,” additional evidence of how bias and misinterpretation factor in a multi-discipline psychobiography.
The researcher’s cognizance of hermeneutic compatibility to the ethos and philosophy of the subject is highly susceptible to error due, much in part, to the varying definitions and understandings that accompany all manner of texts. A psychobiographer is compelled to identify the extent of the hermeneutic contribution to the subject’s worldview but is, likewise, influenced by those sources relied upon for evidence and affirmation. To Esalen biographer, Jeffrey J. Kripal (2007, 61), hermeneutics is “a model that recognizes a truly profound engagement with a text [that] can alter both the received meaning of the text and one’s own meaning and being.”
Murphy’s broad expanse of interests is served well by the hermeneutic circle as his belief system compliments his concept of advanced human potential. AHP is closely tied to the theory of involution-evolution which posits that the energy and capacity of divinity are thrust into the basest of evolutionary particles, expanding in sympathy with human consciousness. Hermeneutic evaluations were essential to Murphy’s theme of religious, spiritual, metaphysical, and scientific comparability. Aurobindo Ghose’s (2006) cultivation of a multi-runged ladder to Supermind corroborates the evolution of human consciousness which supports advanced human potential.
Exegetical scrutiny evidences the symbiotic relationship of Teilhard de Chardin’s (1974) Omega Point to Ghose’s Supermind, and Murphy’s (2012) Supernature. A review of relevant religious, spiritual, and philosophical commentaries grounded the study’s construct and allowed comparison with Murphy’s ethos and activities. Cooper (2006) was particularly helpful in understanding various interpretations of evolutionary panentheism; and Myers (1907, 1918) and Thurston (1951) assisted in the information and documentation of metanormal human potential.
Interpretations and Intuitions
The psychobiographic, in-depth, case study is a reconstructive, intuitive, interpretive method based upon the synthesis of all available evidence culled from all available sciences providing systematic analyses of information on the life and life’s works of a single individual (Erickson (2003, 40).
This conclusion is supported by other theorists (Runyan 1984, McAdams 2001) and by the methods of personality comprehension enabled by the psychological in-depth case study. It is within this context that things get rocky as the constituents of misinformation (speculation, intuition, interpretation, inference, and so on) are subject to bias, error, and misinformation. Runyan (1984, 47) offers the following benchmarks to mitigate explicit misinformation:
Explanations and interpretations can be evaluated in light of criteria such as (1) their logical soundness, (2) their comprehensiveness in accounting for a number of puzzling aspects of the events in question, (3) their survival of tests of attempted falsification, such as tests of derived predictions or retrodictions, (4) their consistency with the full range of available relevant evidence, (5) their support from above, or their consistency with more general knowledge about human functioning or about the person in question, and (6) their creditability relative to other explanatory hypothesis.
It is evident that much misinformation results from poor choice and poor judgment, a lack of thoroughness, and/or ignorance. Hubris and bias also factor in misleading and erroneous conclusions. McAdams (2001, 114) asks: “To what extent are memories for personal events accurate renditions of what happened or biased reconstructions of the past?” Occasions maturate as events happen and vice-versa. It is nigh on impossible to maintain a firm grasp on their evolutions. Individuals rarely retain accurate recollections of the day, time, circumstance, or other exacting details of Pillemer’s triune events in the creation of an occasion. However, memories and their interpretations, whether correctly recollected or not, should not be taken as false or intentionally inaccurate. In the best-case scenario, one creates the best and most honorable recollection of which one is capable.
For we can always make mistakes about the motivation and the principal actors in a study; they can indeed spread misconceptions about their motives. However, the work of a great poet or innovator, religious genius or philosopher can never be anything but the pure expression of the individual’s spiritual life; in that human community delivered from all falsehood, such a work is ever real and unlike every other type of expression registered in signs; it is susceptible to complete and objective interpretation; indeed, it is only in the light of such works that we begin to understand the other contemporary artistic monuments and historical actions (Dilthey and Jameson 1972, 233).
How close to the firemust a researcher’s feet be held? Many insist that academic sources used in support of an argument ease the propensity for misinformation but that is not the case. Any decent researcher can glean sources that support any conclusion one chooses to deliver. A standard academic practice requires the grad-student render a coherent paper, which conclusions are in opposition to the student’s ethos and convictions.
A researcher must always consider the multiplicities of truth. Truth means different things to different people. It is contingent upon the validity of recollection and information provided by the subject, sources, and contemporaries. The researcher is highly susceptible to incorporating personal sensibilities and is subject to misinterpretation due to the vicariousness elements of investigation, the suggestiveness of the subject, and the researchers own condition. As beauty is in the eye of the beholder, so also does truth evidence its ambiguity.
Conclusion
The psychobiography employs many methodologies, its conclusions subject to researcher’s ability to locate fact within abundance. Qualitative research focuses on examining a topic via cultural phenomena, human behavior, and belief systems. A comprehensive study of the life and productivity of an individual can make use of interviews, open-ended questions, opinion research, and so on to gain insight into certain beliefs, concepts, and systems. It offers a close-up look at the human side of an issue concerning behaviors, beliefs, opinions, emotions, and relationships, supported by such intangible factors as social norms, esoteric beliefs, ethnicity, socio-economic status, philosophy, religion, etcetera.
The inherently personalistic aspect of the in-depth case study opens up avenues of misinterpretation as does the study of the phenomenological which is inherently subjective. Add to this the interpretative nature of a psychological inquiry, which is formulated by instinct, speculation, and inference. These overarching requisites for interpretation provide ample room for misinformation. The tenets within any hermeneutic are extremely difficult to fathom. Many texts subject to evaluation are products of another age and civilization, originating in a language open to interpretation.
Take, for example, Buddha’s Noble Truth. The word “dukkha” or suffering that underscores the Four Nobel Truths is translated in multiple ways including anxiety, constraint, distress, and so on. Suffering connotes a purgatorial existence of physical torture, which is counterproductive in its gravity of message. The more reasonable condition of humanity is a state of disillusionment. For the record, this view is a perfectly valid and reasonable consideration. It’s a rational and intelligent revision and is theoretically correct. Many will disagree, some may call it cavalier.
So, do these predilections to misinformation and misinterpretation render a study obsolete? The contrary is true. A subject, researcher, or source is not without fault; it is this susceptibility to error, mistake, bias, motivation, and so on that establishes the humanness and authenticity of the participants. A multivalent psychobiography does not diminish the final product but enhances it through its complexities of comprehension. It is always fortuitous that a good psychobiography not end-up in the academic wasteland of the unforgettable but rise into forums of debate and commentary.
Sources
Atwood, G. E. and Stolorow, R. D. (1993). Faces in a Crowd: Intersubjectivity in Personality Theory. London: Jason Aronson.
Atwood, G. E. and Stolorow, R. D. (1984). Structures of Subjectivity: Explorations in Psychoanalytic Phenomenology. Hillsdale, NJ: Analytic Press.
Collingwood, R. G. (1946). The Idea of History. New York: Oxford University Press,
Cooper, J. W. (2006). Panentheism: The Other God of the Philosophers–From Plato to the Present. Michigan: Baker Academic.
Dilthey, W. (1961). Meaning in History. London: Allen and Unwin.
Dilthey, W. & Jameson, F. (1972). Rise of Hermeneutics. The Johns Hopkins University Press, 3(2), 239-244. http://www.jstor.org/stable/468313. Accessed June 2013.
Erickson, B. J. (2003). A Psychobiography of Richard Price: Co-founder of Esalen Institute. Santa Barbara, CA: Fielding Graduate Institute. doi: 3106741.
Erikson, E. H. (1958). Young Man Luther. A Study in Psychoanalysis and History. New York: Norton and Company, Inc.
Esalen Institute Database. (2014). Esalen TRACK TWO. http://www.trackii.com/accomplishments.html. Accessed June 2013.
Ghose, A. (2006). The Life Divine. Pondicherry, India: Śri Aurobindo Ashram.
Harris, D. (2010). Michael Murphy and the True Home Field Advantage. In J. Ogilvy (Ed.). An Actual Man. Michael Murphy and the Human Potential Movement (pp.113-12O). Berkeley: Minuteman Press.
Hosinski, T. E. (1993). Stubborn Fact and Creative Advance: An Introduction to the Metaphysics of Alfred North Whitehead. New York: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers Inc.
Kripal, J. J. (2007). Esalen. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
McAdams, Dan P. (2001). The Psychology of Life Stories. Review of General Psychology, 5(2), 100-122. http://www.sesp.northwestern.edu/docs/ publications/430816076490a3ddfc3fe1. Accessed April 2013.
Mullen, R. F. (2015). Evolutionary Panentheism and Metanormal Human Capacity: A Psychobiography of Michael Murphy. Ann Arbor, MI: ProQuest.
Murphy, M. (1972). Golf in the Kingdom. New York: Penguin Compass.
Murphy, M. (1992). The Future of the Body. Explorations Into the Further Evolution of Human Nature. New York: Jeremy P. Tarcher/Putnam.
Myers, F. W. H., Gurney, E. & Podmore, F. (1918). Phantasms of the Living. New York: University Books,
Myers, F. W. H. & Myers, L. H. Myers. (1907). Human Personality and Its Survival of Bodily Death. New York: Longmans, Green, and Co.
Ogilvy, J. (Ed.). (2010). An Actual Man. Michael Murphy and the Human Potential Movement. Berkeley: Minuteman Press.
Polkinghorne, D. (1983). Methodology for the Human Sciences: Systems of Inquiry. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
Pillemer D. B. (1988). Momentous Events, Vivid Memories. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Runyan, W. M. (1984). Life Histories and Psychobiography. Explorations in Theory and Method. New York: Oxford University Press.
Sparshott, F. E. (1967). Truth in Fiction. The American Society for Aesthetics, 26(1), 3-7. http://www.jstor.org/stable/429239. Accessed Oct. 2014.
Tarnas, R. (2006). Cosmos and Psyche. New York: Penguin Books.
Teilhard de Chardin, P. (1974). Christianity and Evolution. René Hague (Tr.). New York: Harcourt.
Tomkins, C. (1976). Profiles [Michael Murphy] “New Paradigms” The New Yorker. In J. Ogilvy (Ed.). An Actual Man. Michael Murphy and the Human Potential Movement (pp.7-44). Berkeley: Minuteman Press.
Thurston, H. H. C., SJ. (1951). The Physical Phenomenon of Mysticism. Colorado: Roman Catholic Books.
WHY IS YOUR SUPPORT SO NECESSARY AND ESSENTIAL? ReChanneling develops and implements programs to (1) mitigate symptoms of social anxiety and related conditions and (2) pursue personal goals and objectives – harnessing our intrinsic aptitude for extraordinary living. Our paradigmatic approach targets the personality through empathy, collaboration, and program integration utilizing neuroscience and psychology including proactive neuroplasticity, cognitive-behavioral modification, positive psychology, and techniques designed to regenerate self-esteem. All donations support scholarships for groups and workshops.
